Description:
Text transcribed from caption: PC-46112 DISAGREEMENT OVER ORDINATIONS A
Jesuit theologian said that an article he wrote in 1966 was recently
“misinterpreted" by an Episcopal bishop who cited it as support for
invalidating the ordinations of 11 women deacons. Father Frans Josef van
Beeck, S.J. (left), associate professor of systematic theology at Boson
College, said that Episcopal Bishop Arthur A. Vogel of West Missouri (right)
had not drawn the proper conclusions from his 1966 article. In his report to
the Episcopal House of Bishops in August, which voted to declare the
women’s ordinations invalid, Bishop Vogel said that, based on Father van
Beeck’s article, “validity (of ordination) means ecclesiastical
recognition." The Jesuit said that it was “obvious" that Bishop Vogel
attributed “much more substance" to his definition of validity than he
himself had intended for it to have, and that the “warranted" conclusion
from the article would be that the women’s ordinations “was irregular,
but not invalid in the traditional sense." Bishop Vogel has not replied that
it remains his belief that he did not misinterpret Father van Beeck. “More
importantly," he continued, “neither my advisement nor the action of the
House of Bishops depended in any positive way on the theological position of
Father van Beeck." Credit Must Read: RELIGIOUS NEWS SERVICE PHOTO
(A/R-10B-74-DS)
Creator:
Religious News Service. (publisher)
Subject names:
Religious News Service--Archives., Beeck, Frans Jozef van., Boston College. Theology Department--Faculty., Jesuits., Catholic Church--Clergy., Vogel, Arthur A., 1924-2012., Episcopal Church--Bishops., Episcopal Church. Diocese of West Missouri., Episcopal Church. House of Bishops.
Topics:
Clergy--Appointment, call, and election., Ordination--Episcopal Church., Church controversies--Episcopal Church., Women in the Episcopal Church--United States.
URL:
https://digital.history.pcusa.org/islandora/object/islandora:361539