Karen Henry, Big Rapids, Michigan, on Palestine, 1994, side 1.

Primary tabs

Download

  • speaker
    This is Margaret Purchase speaking and I'm recording the talk by Karen Henry
  • speaker
    at Big Rapids Michigan March 24th 1994. I am an Arab Amercian that was
  • speaker
    born and raised in Michigan. My grandparents come from Syria and Lebanon. I grew up in a household where you.
  • speaker
    didn't learn to speak Arabic. And, we're all really sorry, but we've heard enough that we
  • speaker
    begin to recognize some of the sounds as we study it. We certainly did grow up with very much of an Arab culture. And, with the Arab food, which
  • speaker
    I maintain today is still the best food in the entire world. So, I did get a lot of growing up Arab. I made my first trip to the Middle East
  • speaker
    10 years ago. And a little over ten years ago. And, have been to Lebanon once, and to Palestine and Israel three times, living and working in
  • speaker
    Palestine in Jerusalem, for a Palestinian newspaper called El Hadja, which means The Dawn.
  • speaker
    I'm not going to talk about the history of the region. I understand first of all that some of you are studying it and.
  • speaker
    secondly, we don't have very much time. And, you want to engage some stuff
  • speaker
    today. I will simply say a couple of things.
  • speaker
    One is that Arabs have lived in Palestine for over two thousand years.
  • speaker
    When Jews started going to Palestine due to a movement called Zionism and due to the atrocities committed by Hitler,
  • speaker
    that they were accepted by the Arabs living there until they
  • speaker
    had different designs on the area. The other thing I would like to
  • speaker
    say about that is that the movement called Zionism, which is
  • speaker
    often referred to as a religious movement, I think we should look at as
  • speaker
    not a religious movement, but actually a political, nationalist movement. That, in
  • speaker
    fact, the Jews who went to Palestine, went there for a place
  • speaker
    to live. They went for security.
  • speaker
    They went with a political ideology. They went believing they were going to a land without people and that they were the
  • speaker
    people for that land. When they got there, they found out that wasn't the reality. And, Great Britain, which had a
  • speaker
    mandate for the area, made promises to them that they couldn't keep and
  • speaker
    promises to the Palestinians that they couldn't keep. So they were completing promises that created a lot of the strife that we have seen up till today.
  • speaker
    Now in 1948 when Israel declared itself a state,
  • speaker
    It's important for us to realize that the United States was the
  • speaker
    first country to recognize the new
  • speaker
    state of Israel. When you. If you have a flyer about my
  • speaker
    talk. It says I am going to talk about Is peace and justice possible for 27 years of occupation to a massacre in
  • speaker
    a mosque. And, I will talk about that. But I want to focus also
  • speaker
    on perceptions that we have in this country about arabs. I will talk about
  • speaker
    media coverage. First of all, occupation. Probably. The.
  • speaker
    Most of us who live comfortably
  • speaker
    in this country. So what does it mean to live under occupation. I will give you an example from
  • speaker
    what I know, from how some of my friends have lived, and from what it was like for me to
  • speaker
    live in a country that was under Israeli cccupation. This occupation
  • speaker
    has gone on for almost twenty-seven years, which means that to the
  • speaker
    majority of the population, people who are young like most of you in this room, that that is
  • speaker
    all that they have ever known. They have only known life under occupation. Life under occupation
  • speaker
    means you do not have the right to
  • speaker
    vote. It means that schools can be closed by the military authority for
  • speaker
    any reason whatsoever. And they can be closed for long periods of time.
  • speaker
    A particularly insidious thing that has happened. A thing that has happened to students is that when the schools
  • speaker
    are closed by military authority right before final exams.
  • speaker
    Imagine it, if you are a student. It is time for final exams, and military authority
  • speaker
    closes your school.You cannot take your exam.
  • speaker
    You not only cannot take that, if the school opens in a month or too, you've got to go through that entire year of education again before you can take those exams.
  • speaker
    Or at least wait for that entire year to elapse.
  • speaker
    Palestinians are among the
  • speaker
    highest educated people in the entire world. And, they take education seriously. Another thing that happens when you
  • speaker
    live under occupation is you are subject to military curfew. You are subject to a phenomenon known as house demolition. Perhaps some of you have seen on the news
  • speaker
    just recently. What that means is if one member of a family living in a home is suspected. I use the word suspected. Of
  • speaker
    illegal activity that the occupying authorities can come in with bulldozers and bulldoze the home, b
  • speaker
    efore the individual suspected of illegal activity
  • speaker
    is tried in a court of law. This goes against international
  • speaker
    law, but it happens on a daily basis. I was there to view a family, who was given thirty minutes to get out of their home before the bulldozers came. And, a
  • speaker
    family in the Middle East is often more than the three point five people that it
  • speaker
    is in America. It can be as many as seventeen that suddenly find themselves homeless.
  • speaker
    Arrest, imprisonment, administrative detention are all part of
  • speaker
    occupation. House arrest is another item that is part of occupation. House
  • speaker
    arrest meaning that you cannot leave your home between sunset and
  • speaker
    sunrise. If you've been watching CNN and
  • speaker
    some of the other networks that have been talking about so-called peace accords and you've see some of
  • speaker
    those spokespeople on the news--Hanan Ashrawi, Feisal Hussein.
  • speaker
    When I was living in Jerusalem, I was part of a committee with Feisal Hussein
  • speaker
    and other Palestinian and some Israeli Jews who were looking for
  • speaker
    ways to work together and to work against the occupation. But Feisal Hussein
  • speaker
    was under house arrest. So he couldn't leave his home. So we had no choice but to have our meetings at his home, which was often a great inconvenience. So he was under house arrest for
  • speaker
    six months of the year that I was there.
  • speaker
    Part of occupation means that
  • speaker
    members can be exiled, Palestinians can be exiled from their land.
  • speaker
    And that's all done illegal. It breaks up families. Another part of
  • speaker
    occupation is that women are often subject to
  • speaker
    sexual assault by Israeli soldiers and this is something that is not talked about, but it is something that does happen.
  • speaker
    Land. Is stolen stolen. Settlements are built on the land. And another art of
  • speaker
    daily life in the area for example like Gaza, which according
  • speaker
    to some studies, is the most highly populated
  • speaker
    area per capita in the world. If it is not the most highly populated, it
  • speaker
    is extremely highly populated. It also happens
  • speaker
    to be one of the poorest areas in the world. And, it is
  • speaker
    one of the areas that the Israelis have intentionally neglected.
  • speaker
    And, I think that they have neglected Gaza more than they have neglected any other area. Now, in
  • speaker
    Gaza people live in what are called refugee camps. Now they are not tents. They
  • speaker
    are actual buildings and they abut each other. And, the families that live in
  • speaker
    those houses keep those houses spotless. They are spotlessly clean..
  • speaker
    And, they do this without electricity. And, they do this without running
  • speaker
    water in many cases. And, the people are spotlessly clean. Their clothes are clean.
  • speaker
    The children are clean, but they
  • speaker
    don't have, as I said, running water. They don't have sewage. What they have instead is the gullies, the open gullies in
  • speaker
    some of the camps, where the sewage runs open. I was there one
  • speaker
    summer during an especially hot day, a hundred and fifteen degrees.
  • speaker
    And, the children are outside playing. And, it is really hot, and there is no running water, and the only
  • speaker
    water running anywhere through the camp is running through the gullies and it is sewage. And, the children find it
  • speaker
    irresistible to taste the water, and so they do occasionally. And, they get diseased. And, Israel, which is the occupying power, turns its back on them. So, these are examples of what life under occupation is like for the i
  • speaker
    ndigenous population.
  • speaker
    During the 27 years of occupation and during the Intifada, the
  • speaker
    population hasn't just sat there and waited to be
  • speaker
    arrested. What has been done during this period is build the infrastructure
  • speaker
    of a society. There is a sliding legitimate
  • speaker
    society. Palestinian society.
  • speaker
    Education. There is kindergarten.Women especially deal with illiteracy. There are health services. Production.
  • speaker
    They organized demonstrations. They do things like job training and I'm talking
  • speaker
    about this in Gaza about one thing. Aside from the political organization
  • speaker
    and the Palestine Liberation Organization. That this is the infrastructure of society that
  • speaker
    has been worked up over twenty-seven years.
  • speaker
    So with this backdrop, with that brief backdrop, we've got to the point where something
  • speaker
    historic happened. And, it was
  • speaker
    called the "Signing of the Declaration of Principles."
  • speaker
    Story. And, what I like to call the historic handshake between Yassir Arafat and Izaak Rabin.
  • speaker
    So. People, it seems, were so euphoric about the handshake. Two enemies actually shaking hands that
  • speaker
    there wasn't very much analysis about what kind of a deal was this.
  • speaker
    What exactly were they shaking hands on? Well in my personal opinion it was a very b
  • speaker
    ad deal. Because it was an unequal deal and the Palestinians were coming
  • speaker
    out low. But I also believe that bad deals can
  • speaker
    turn out OK because, if your intention is good, and if the parties involved really care and work on it, things can turn out,
  • speaker
    turn out for the best. Why was it a bad deal? It was a bad deal because at no point did
  • speaker
    they talk about self-determination for the Palestinians. At no point, in other words, did
  • speaker
    they talk about real freedom for the Palestinians. A Palestinian state was not mentioned. It was a bad deal because a lot of people were left out of the deal, particularly those who were living under armed occupation. It was a bad deal because
  • speaker
    prisoners were not
  • speaker
    part of the deal. The exiles were not part of the deal. Jerusalem was not part of the deal. Neither were the Palestinians in the diaspora. The economic issue the water issue, none of them was really dealt with.  On the other hand, t
  • speaker
    here was something good about the deal.
  • speaker
    Israel recognized the P.L.O. for the first time ever.
  • speaker
    Jews and Palestinians in that land are talking to each other. They've always been talking to each other, but our media's never
  • speaker
    really talked about it.
  • speaker
    But now, they're talking to each other, and we are talking about them talking to each other.
  • speaker
    Another good thing is that the P.L.O. is actually examining itself and realizing that perhaps it has got to make some changes. One of
  • speaker
    the big problems
  • speaker
    is that the USA, which is involved in these talks, is
  • speaker
    extremely biased. And, we are going to talk about that next and has treated both parties as though they are spirits. And as though there is actual equality
  • speaker
    between Israel and Palestine. And, in fact, there is no equality
  • speaker
    of calling yet. There
  • speaker
    is certainly the equality of color, but there certainly is no equality of power. and they cannot be treated as though there is.
  • speaker
    So what that brings me to as a U.S.
  • speaker
    citizen is born and raised in this country is. What is my responsibility? I am a taxpayer. Six billion
  • speaker
    dollars a
  • speaker
    year goes to Israel and I pay taxes for that.
  • speaker
    So. What is it that has to do with me? Do I need to be responsible for this? What does our government represent when it gets involved in dealing conflicts?. Well, let us talk about the current government, w
  • speaker
    hich is the Clinton administration, which actually happens to be the
  • speaker
    worst administration in history of this country for Arabs, and especially for Palestinians. What has happened under the Clinton administration is that
  • speaker
    United States dollars
  • speaker
    have been used for settlements. And, settlements are supposed to be by
  • speaker
    international law illegal. Previous administrations at least had the pretense of not using our tax dollars or grants and loan monies to Israel f
  • speaker
    or an internationally illegal item like settlements, but this administration doesn't even bother with the pretense. This administration ignores international law
  • speaker
    more than any previous administration.
  • speaker
    This administration could just that Jerusalem actually belongs to Israel. And, there is no country in the world, including this country, that recognizes
  • speaker
    Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. Jerusalem, the city, whose status is still to be negotiated.
  • speaker
    There was a U.S. State Department report on Israeli settlements, which showed
  • speaker
    that there was continued settling in east Jerusalem. That is against the law and past presidents, including Bush, approved for.  That does not mean I voted for George Bush, by the way. I voted for my
  • speaker
    mother. Actually, I thought it would be nice to have an Arab woman president. A
  • speaker
    nother thing that the Clinton administration has done. It has allowed the four hundred and fifteen
  • speaker
    Palestinian exiles to
  • speaker
    languish in Lebanon. It allowed this obvious breach of
  • speaker
    international law to occur. And when the UN Security Council resolution
  • speaker
    was about to get adopted, saying that this is an Illegal act, and the exiles needed to be returned immediately,
  • speaker
    the United States with its power undercut the
  • speaker
    resolution before it could read the board. And said. No. As long
  • speaker
    as Israel lets them back a few at a time, even if it takes a year, that that
  • speaker
    satisfies the letter of the law. It did not.
  • speaker
    Disputed Territories. Now we have talked for years, for almost
  • speaker
    27 years, about occupied territories, about the territories that are to be
  • speaker
    negotiated. Territories Israel took in wars that n
  • speaker
    eed to be returned, like the Sinai wa returned to Egypt. The West Bank and
  • speaker
    Gaza are occupied territories. The only people who call the
  • speaker
    occupied territories "disputed territories" are the Israeli Jews, who feel that they should not be  returned or people that also support
  • speaker
    the fact that those territories belong to Israel. The
  • speaker
    Clinton administration has been using the term "disputed territories."
  • speaker
    I find this to be dishonest. The U.S. drafts papers on the peace accords,
  • speaker
    because we were so involved in the peace accords that we
  • speaker
    were drafting papers on how they should be worded and what should be said.
  • speaker
    Never. Never call the territories occupied. Another thing about the Clinton administration is that
  • speaker
    after the massacre in Hebron [Cave of the Patriarchs massacre]. The massacre of praying Muslims in a mosque. The President of the United States got up and
  • speaker
    publicly said, "This was a gross act of murder, but
  • speaker
    extremists on both sides are trying to derail the peace process." As though a similar
  • speaker
    act had been perpetrated against
  • speaker
    Israeli Jews praying by Palestinians. This
  • speaker
    was an unconscionable statement and nobody called him on it. It was an unconscionable statement. What he
  • speaker
    did was showed us that there is a
  • speaker
    premium on a certain kind of life. And, the premium in this case is on the lives of our allies, the Jews and not on the lives of the Arabs
  • speaker
    In addition, Clinton has surrounded himself with supporters of Israel. And, I use this term loosely
  • speaker
    because I think that
  • speaker
    a lot of people that are called supporters of Israel, actually don't have Israel's best interests at heart. Among them are Al Gore, who says that Israel, Israel
  • speaker
    is America's best friend in the entire world.
  • speaker
    The National Security Council Middle East desk is run by a man named Martin Indyk [Indyk, Martin Sean]. And Martin Indyk was at one time associated with AIPAC [America Israel Public Affairs Committee]. AIPAC
  • speaker
    is the pro-Israel lobby in this country.
  • speaker
    He also is a supporter of the Likud. The Likud is the Israeli
  • speaker
    Party that is a very right wing, hardline party. And, he is running the Middle East desk at the National Security Council. Samuel Lewis [Lewis, Samuel Winfield] in the State Department is a former ambassador to Israel and is a
  • speaker
    currently a
  • speaker
    fundraiser for the Israeli government. Dennis Ross [Ross, Dennis B.] and Mickey Kantor [Kantor, Michael]. Dennis
  • speaker
    Ross is involved in the negotiations and Mickey Kantor, who is the trade representative, and others
  • speaker
    are all
  • speaker
    AIPAC people. Now. There is something wrong with the
  • speaker
    president getting all of his advice from people who have one vision.
  • speaker
    If, in fact, these were some of his advisors and he
  • speaker
    had other advisors, who said, "Look! You need to look at this side of the picture well,"
  • speaker
    it would be a different story. But he doesn't.
  • speaker
    We often said. And, we also send, as I told you earlier, six billion
  • speaker
    dollars of aid to Israel per year with no
  • speaker
    accountability. That is almost one third ot the total of the U.S. foreign aid package. And, we can't ask for accountability. I had Israeli Jewish friends, like Matthew  Kellot, who is a former
  • speaker
    member of the Knesset. And these people write articles saying, "United States. Stop sending Israel so much money. It is not helping us at all."
  • speaker
    It is allowing us to continue to defy international law. It's allowing us to
  • speaker
    continue to prop up the military. And, it is allowing us to continue avoiding solving our problems. Ok. That's
  • speaker
    the Clinton administration. That's the administration that did not respond in my estimation to the massacre at the mosque.
  • speaker
    Now,when the massacre at the mosque occurred [Cave of the Patriarchs, February 25, 1994], the
  • speaker
    first thing I did was try really hard to watch as much media coverage of it as I could. And, that's hard to do because sometimes it's difficult to watch..
  • speaker
    And I found
  • speaker
    that almost everybody was saying that this was the act of a lone gunman [Goldstein, Baruch Kopel]. One, demented person. And, it could never happen again. What I'd like to say is that this was a logical outcome of
  • speaker
    27 years of occupation. That this was the logical outcome. And, first of all, I don't believe he acted alone. I think that he probably did not act alone.
  • speaker
    But whether he did or didn't, it was still a logical act of state-sponsored terrorism. Of a
  • speaker
    country that has a rule that says you can
  • speaker
    never shoot a Jew, even if the Jew is shooting Palestinians. This is the logical outcome.
  • speaker
    Settlers. The settlers are armed. And, they are almost always armed. And, they go everywhere with their arms. They go with their lavelier assault rifles and with their Uzis, and with their M-16s.  They
  • speaker
    walk into the church of the Holy Sepulcher in the old city, carrying their guns.
  • speaker
    Those of us, Jews, Arabs,
  • speaker
    Americans, Brits. Those of us that see that, stay away,
  • speaker
    because we fell that that is a very inflammatory thing. We don't want to be around these folks
  • speaker
    carrying their weapons. They are always armed. Somewhere
  • speaker
    violence has happened since the beginning, and it has never been stopped. In Hebron, where the massacre occurred and where Baruch Goldstein c
  • speaker
    ame from, Kiryat Arba, which
  • speaker
    I consider to be a Fascist settlement
  • speaker
    It is a right-wing, hard-line Fascist settlement. He was a product of that settlement, and the
  • speaker
    Israeli Jews who settled in that area would overturn crates in park in the market at Hebron. They would spray insecticide on the food. They would spit at people.
  • speaker
    And, according
  • speaker
    to Washington Report on Middle Eastern Affairs, there were some eyewitnesses to watching
  • speaker
    some of those Israelis Jews, who had passed by some Palestinians, who were burying one of their children, who was
  • speaker
    shot by the military. And, they
  • speaker
    walked past and shouted, "Mazel tov", which means "good luck and congratulations." And, this has been going on for a long
  • speaker
    time.
  • speaker
    Now in the midst of all that, in my criticism of the hard line settlers and of
  • speaker
    the policies of the government. And, I do recall I criticize the Israeli government and the American government very strongly.
  • speaker
    I would like to see them been and continue to be more than a handful
  • speaker
    of Israeli Jews who are appalled by what is happening in their country. And, at great risk to themselves,  they have stood up,
  • speaker
    spoken out about it, and taken as much action as they can.
  • speaker
    And often found themselves in jail as a result. They need our support.
  • speaker
    Now. How does the media cover all this? How am I doing on time? I tend to talk. How does the media cover this/  How does the media cover Arabs in general?
  • speaker
    First of all. We're either a bomber
  • speaker
    Or we're a billionaire or we're a belly dancer, and that's about
  • speaker
    it. I mean you don't really see us as anything other than
  • speaker
    one of those three  things. I've gone around throughout Michigan to speak. And, I am billed as an Arab American, because that is what I call myself, based on my pride, and also based on my necessity to say that. And, people expect me to be something other than what I am. And, they expect me.  First of all, they expect me to be veiled and not to be able to really talk
  • speaker
    And, they don't expect me to say, to make any analysis or to be able
  • speaker
    to interact with other people. We have to get past that. The problem with that is the tv novels, comics, cartoons, and movies show us as rich, ugly, if we are men
  • speaker
    Sexually available, veiled virgins if we're women, but don't show as human. And, our leaders
  • speaker
    In this country contribute to the atmosphere. People like Jeane Kirkpatrick,
  • speaker
    who was representative to the United Nations, who say publicly that Arabs have a history of
  • speaker
    violent politics. Henry Kissinger said publicly you
  • speaker
    can't believe anything an Arab tells you. There was no outcry. That is unbelievable to me. CNN does a report. It does a report about Jewish kids and their response to this m
  • speaker
    assacre [Cave of the Patriarchs]. And the Jewish kids in Israel.
  • speaker
    say this massacre was awful. We've got to give up some land for peace. We don't want to keep living like this. They talked to
  • speaker
    four or five groups of Jewish kids. And then they showed the final shot. And, the final shot is
  • speaker
    children in Gaza. But nobody talks to the children in Gaza to ask how they felt. Why not?
  • speaker
    And, the Grand Rapids Press, we see headlines like "Rabin remains steadfast." He remains steadfast
  • speaker
    after Palestinians said, "Look. We've just had fifty of our people massacred, maybe more. And, we need some protection." And, he said, "No."
  • speaker
    So. He's not called intransigent? He's called steadfast? I'm urging all of you, pay attention when you read the newspaper. Pay attention when you hear the news. Listen to those buzz words.
  • speaker
    Find out what those buzz words do to you. If it says "terrorist," its dumb. But if it says, "soldier," it's us or our ally. "Us" meaning American. "
  • speaker
    Hard line" is down. "Resolute"  is up. "Inflexible" is
  • speaker
    down, but "firm" is up. Hear it after theirs. Ours is a tragic error. Now. We hear this stuff all the time, but we usually don't stop to analyze
  • speaker
    how it makes us perceive the
  • speaker
    news. And,we need to start doing that because, if we do that, we will perceive the news differently.  Those stereotypes and those kinds of headlines really hurt us.The CNN headline that the Israelis are on high alert. That's the headline. So, you immediately think
  • speaker
    "Oh! My gosh! Something bad is happening to Israel.
  • speaker
    What has
  • speaker
    happened is that the Israelis shot into a crowd and wounded twenty Arabs. The headline is Israelis on high alert.
  • speaker
    Something is wrong with that. How many people heard about what
  • speaker
    happened at the funeral of Baruch Goldstein in Israel, when
  • speaker
    another Israeli settler said,
  • speaker
    One million Arabs are not worth a Jewish fingernail.
  • speaker
    Why was there not an outcry about that? There should have been an outcry about that. What I want to say is that those kinds of headlines lead to acts of
  • speaker
    racism. And
  • speaker
    those racist acts then get lost.
  • speaker
    During the U.S.A. war against Iraq, what was called the Persian Gulf
  • speaker
    War, I was walking into a shop in Grand Rapids. And, what I saw in a huge display with
  • speaker
    teeshirts,
  • speaker
    several teeshirts. And, all of them said the same thing. They said, "I'd fly ten thousand
  • speaker
    miles to smoke a camel." And, in the center of the teeshirt was a circle. And, when I got closer, I realized that that circle was the sight of a gun. And, through the sight of the gun, there was an Arab sitting on the camel.
  • speaker
    We talked, my friends here and I, talked to the man
  • speaker
    who made that teeshirt. We said, "Would you have said that if it was, 'I'd fly ten thousand miles to smoke a Jew? Or a black?'  And, he said, "Oh, no! I've got my limits."
  • speaker
    There's
  • speaker
    something wrong with this and we're letting it happen.
  • speaker
    There was another CNN. You can tell I don't like CNN. headline that says
  • speaker
    That two Israeli soldiers were killed in the so-called security zone in Lebanon, an area where they are actually in illegal occupation. They were killed in the security zone
  • speaker
    by supposedly Hezbollah. In retaliation, Israel shelled a market place, killing a twelve-year
  • speaker
    old
  • speaker
    girl and injuring twenty-two children. That item was disappeared from the news the next day. Try to put
  • speaker
    any other group of people in there and
  • speaker
    tell me, "Would that item have disappeared from the news the next day?" There is something wrong with this.
  • speaker
    I. I've done a lot of speaking with a friend of mine who happens
  • speaker
    to be an American Jew. And whenever we speak
  • speaker
    People will say to me, now, you do believe in Israel's right to exist, don't you?  That, they do not want to hear me talk unless I say I believe in Israel's right to exist.
  • speaker
    Nobody says to me, "You
  • speaker
    do believe in Palestine's right to exist, don't you?" That is a double standard. And, it is a double standard we now take for granted.
  • speaker
    I want to say a couple of things about hope, because I'm not leaving time for anybody to ask questions, because there are things to be hopeful about. And, one of them was
  • speaker
    that my
  • speaker
    Jewish friend and I wrote a letter to our newspaper
  • speaker
    together after the massacre [Cave of the Patriarchs] in the mosque. And, we both sent it, and we talked
  • speaker
    about it being a product of a violent society. And I think that that's something to feel hopeful about.
  • speaker
    There are other things that make me feel hopeful. There was recently a World Day of Prayer by Church Women United.
  • speaker
    And, the prayer service was written by Palestinian women. And it was very strong and very
  • speaker
    beautiful and that was celebrated all over the world. We can also
  • speaker
    celebrate the fact that there are Jews and Arabs who have been
  • speaker
    friends and have talked
  • speaker
    to each other for years. And, that they form alliances, and they do so no matter what the political situation is
  • speaker
    There is a group of Jewish women called Women in Black, who every Friday stand in different squares in their country, pulling aside against the occupation
  • speaker
    Even though they get yelled at and called whores of Arafat.
  • speaker
    And they get spit at. That other people come up to them and
  • speaker
    give them
  • speaker
    flowers and give them fruit. And as they stay there every week. And they have done this for more, for more than a year.
  • speaker
    more than a year. One final thing is.
  • speaker
    That it is important that you all speak
  • speaker
    out. That when you recognize this stuff that you speak out about it. It is important that we listen to the
  • speaker
    voices of Arabs. I repeat. That it is important that we listen to the voices of Arabs. I took a class called "The Arab-Israeli Conflict" at the University of Michigan just a few years ago. Our list of r
  • speaker
    eading material had three Israelis, six American Jews, not
  • speaker
    one Arab. Something is wrong with this. This is a huge university.
  • speaker
    You need to listen to the voices of Arabs. Arabs deserve to be heard, and it is up to us to ask them to talk. We have to object
  • speaker
    to government policies, and above all. it was my proper call about is there any hope? Yeah. Is there any hope
  • speaker
    for justice and peace?
  • speaker
    There is. And one of the things that we can do is go right back to the United
  • speaker
    Nations General Assembly, Article 19, adopted in
  • speaker
    1948, which is the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. I wish I had the Declaration with me. But what it does, it affirms
  • speaker
    the full
  • speaker
    human rights of every single person on this planet. And if, in fact, you believe that and follow
  • speaker
    international law. There will be some hope for justice and peace in the Middle East and maybe even here at home.
  • speaker
    Questions? I know you've got like five minutes before a lot of us have to get out of here. Discussion, questions, comments? Announcements: One
  • speaker
    of the organizations of Grand Rapids that my colleagues and I do work with is called
  • speaker
    the Institute for Global Education. Middle East education project. The Middle East Education Project has put on a lot of events and seminars. A seminar called understanding Islam, where we've had speakers that are cultural people, educated people about that religion, and what it is like to live it.
  • speaker
    We all have the speaker, who is the Rev. Dr. Don Wagner, who is the Director
  • speaker
    of Mercy Corps in Chicago, who will be coming to speak in Grand Rapids
  • speaker
    on May 4 at 7:30 at the Eberhard Center. He has
  • speaker
    just written a book called  Peace or Armageddon and he will be giving a
  • speaker
    talk. And, we have entitled his talk," Peace or Armageddon: the Holy Land in Turmoil." He has been to Palestine recently and has an eyewitness account that I think will be of interest. He has made
  • speaker
    a study of the area and of
  • speaker
    Armageddon for years and is very capable of answering any questions as well.
  • speaker
    So, we invite you to that. Are we going to have this photocopied? Are you going to make a photocopy of this? And make it available maybe? Can we leave it with you?  There you go. Is this a political or a religious conflict? It is everything. But it is primarily a political, economic, empowerment kind of conflict
  • speaker
    Religion figures into it, but I think that is one of the mistakes that we make is that we talk about it being a religious conflict. I will make this comment, however. It wasn't a mistake that Baruch Goldstein shot muslims. I think that was the intent. He did not go into a church. I think that his intent was to shoot and kill muslims. But I wouldn't say that the conflict itself is religious in nature. The conflict has to do with a lack of justice and that is . If there is no comment about the massacre in Hebron massacre. come to New York with his wife and children before the massacre. a million dollars.  And they now will not do that. Secondly, about Gaza Strip because it is the most populated area in the world. There are no resources. Nothing in there except people. And the Israelis look at it, and find bombs. They don't want it. That is why they are going peace treaty,
  • speaker
    The peace accords are a clear no. They don't want it.That is the other thing.
  • speaker
    I am not allowed to move back to Gaza before nine months. I need to go now. People
  • speaker
    have not come back before I am not allowed to come back before nine months. Now, after the peace treaty, they started a revolution.
  • speaker
    twenty-five years, because I am older than, I am allowed to
  • speaker
    These are some of the pictures that we never saw that came out of the Gulf War. And, this is how we censored ourselves in this country
  • speaker
    that we did not have to realize what a horrible war this was. This is a
  • speaker
    soldier who was actually trying to comply with the United Nations resolution that said you've
  • speaker
    got to leave the area, the Iraqui soldiers leave the area. And, it was believed they would leave the
  • speaker
    area. As they were departing. This is called lutlana. As they
  • speaker
    were leaving on the road, which is dubbed the highway to death.
  • speaker
    What happened is, it was just unbelievable is that we shelled them. We pounded them at both ends. He was retreating, and
  • speaker
    we made sure he never got out. These pictures didn't come out, but one of the generals was asked why. He said, my goodness if you showed pictures like this, there'd never be another war. I think he's wrong about that, a
  • speaker
    ctually. I think we've seen horrible pictures, and I think we're still willing to go to war.
  • speaker
    But it is important to recognize  that we did a lot of censorship of this kind.  And we continue to do censorship. I
  • speaker
    didn't know about the eighty-five percent unemployment in Gaza.
  • speaker
    I work. I worked in college. I work sometimes  for eight months. Still I am unemployed.
  • speaker
    Shown several times. That is all right. On the other hand. an Israeli civilian. He is not a civilian. This
  • speaker
    is my
  • speaker
    Of course, it is compulsory, both men and women, Most of them carry rifles, even the ladies, they carry M-16, Israeli, Uzi, all kinds of weapons. For us,    Hebron, Gaza Strip.  A Palestinian woman was killed and she was pregnant. They said even that the Palestinians killed her. How could we kill one of us?
  • speaker
    And they control the house. and how should we kill a lady walking the streets. We not shoot.  If you walk in the Gaza Strip without a leader you might get shot. It is not easy.Snipers and.
  • speaker
    Open the.
  • speaker
    Them and. maybe You know
  • speaker
    the main reason why you.
  • speaker
    The universities were closed, the schools 1987.
  • speaker
    And I just remember talking about Jerusalem. I had been in Jerusalem for twelve months. One day, I was going to pray at Dome Rock in Jerusalem. And
  • speaker
    I was stopped at the gate for
  • speaker
    identification to get through to the mosque. And, I was beaten up by the soldiers
  • speaker
    simply because I am
  • speaker
    from the North, and simply because I insisted to go to the mosque for Friday prayers. I was taken out to the hospital.
  • speaker
    I still have eight stitches in
  • speaker
    my chest simply because I insisted. Since
  • speaker
    I was a kid. I thought the Arab-Israeli, pursuing the Israel conflict is a very complicated issue
  • speaker
    or equation. Now, I believe it is very simple from both sides. U.S. aid to Israel will cause equal killings of innocent Palestinians. I was told two years ago in summer of 1992, and I couldn't stay there. I was there four years.  I couldn't stay there
  • speaker
    Because I couldn't find my friend.
  • speaker
    And, you cannot ask.

Bookmark

BookBags: