Cliff Kirkpatrick oral history, 2023.

Primary tabs

Download

  • speaker
    All right. Today is Thursday, the
  • speaker
    7th of September,
  • speaker
    2023. And this is our third
  • speaker
    conversation with the Reverand
  • speaker
    Doctor Clifton Kirkpatrick,
  • speaker
    Stated Clerk Emeritus
  • speaker
    of the General Assembly of the
  • speaker
    Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) who
  • speaker
    also served as a past president
  • speaker
    of the World Alliance of Reformed
  • speaker
    Churches and is
  • speaker
    a retired professor of ecumenical
  • speaker
    studies and world Christianity
  • speaker
    at Louisville Presbyterian
  • speaker
    Theological Seminary.
  • speaker
    And this is a continuing
  • speaker
    series as part of the oral history
  • speaker
    project sponsored
  • speaker
    by the Presbyterian Historical
  • speaker
    Society.
  • speaker
    Cliff, it's so good to be with you
  • speaker
    today.
  • speaker
    We had such rich conversations, the
  • speaker
    last two conversations.
  • speaker
    Well, I appreciate it too.
  • speaker
    Glad we finally made this happen
  • speaker
    because it's worth it.
  • speaker
    And I am grateful
  • speaker
    that you stuck with it and got
  • speaker
    it to--got it this point.
  • speaker
    I look forward to, you know, the
  • speaker
    conversation today.
  • speaker
    Indeed. And it is a--it's a blessing
  • speaker
    because you were a part
  • speaker
    of and you helped shape the
  • speaker
    history of us Presbyterians and
  • speaker
    really the reformed family worldwide
  • speaker
    in the
  • speaker
    various
  • speaker
    ministry calls that you've had over
  • speaker
    the past decades.
  • speaker
    And so in our--.
  • speaker
    In our continuing conversation
  • speaker
    where we left off--.
  • speaker
    And so why don't we cover
  • speaker
    where we left off, as we were
  • speaker
    talking about during your
  • speaker
    first term as Stated Clerk
  • speaker
    of the General Assembly,
  • speaker
    you had led a PC(USA) delegation
  • speaker
    to the Vatican.
  • speaker
    Yes.
  • speaker
    And you had
  • speaker
    the opportunity to have a personal
  • speaker
    audience with the Holy Father, then
  • speaker
    Pope John Paul II.
  • speaker
    Can you share a little--?
  • speaker
    That's one I'll never--I'll never
  • speaker
    forget, and I think I've shared
  • speaker
    that with you, that what we were
  • speaker
    not expecting happened with a
  • speaker
    very gracious outreach by the Pope.
  • speaker
    What we had--. Basically, we had
  • speaker
    come into a conversation
  • speaker
    at the Vatican out of an invitation
  • speaker
    from the--from the Holy Father
  • speaker
    that [we] wanted
  • speaker
    to pursue our relationships
  • speaker
    back and forth.
  • speaker
    But had--.
  • speaker
    When we got there, we
  • speaker
    had the usual. He read a paper.
  • speaker
    I read a paper.
  • speaker
    We went back and forth, and finally
  • speaker
    he set the script aside and
  • speaker
    said, "Well, we may keep going, but
  • speaker
    as far as I'm concerned,
  • speaker
    arrivederci." And then he put in
  • speaker
    every language that people spoke
  • speaker
    manly the [unclear] language,
  • speaker
    and we were wishing arrivederci
  • speaker
    to everybody there.
  • speaker
    Reminds you that when we think of
  • speaker
    all these, you know, formal matters,
  • speaker
    that there's some real human flesh
  • speaker
    and blood that's behind them.
  • speaker
    And it makes it a good story
  • speaker
    and a good experience.
  • speaker
    And at least one
  • speaker
    sign of the--of the humanity
  • speaker
    and good spirit
  • speaker
    of the people in the Vatican
  • speaker
    was one that took place that day.
  • speaker
    That's wonderful.
  • speaker
    That's wonderful. So it's those
  • speaker
    lighthearted moments where
  • speaker
    the--where the
  • speaker
    full humanity of people and--and
  • speaker
    the relationships matter.
  • speaker
    So great for that.
  • speaker
    And it--. You had shared before
  • speaker
    that was
  • speaker
    one among several, right? One
  • speaker
    among several ecumenical
  • speaker
    engagements that you had
  • speaker
    as Stated Clerk at the General
  • speaker
    Assembly with the
  • speaker
    Roman Catholic Church.
  • speaker
    Is that right?
  • speaker
    Yes.
  • speaker
    Well, there were a number of those.
  • speaker
    And it's a credit
  • speaker
    both to the Presbyterian Church
  • speaker
    but also to the Vatican
  • speaker
    that there's been that kind of
  • speaker
    conscious outreach.
  • speaker
    We know that some of the rules
  • speaker
    and procedures kind of get as a
  • speaker
    barrier between us.
  • speaker
    But--but
  • speaker
    when you really press it deep, we
  • speaker
    have the common line[?] [that] created
  • speaker
    the reconciliation,
  • speaker
    for involvement of people to work
  • speaker
    for justice. And you
  • speaker
    get a feeling at the end that
  • speaker
    arrivederci is also a
  • speaker
    welcome sense
  • speaker
    about being together
  • speaker
    for the cause of Christ.
  • speaker
    That's right. Amen.
  • speaker
    Amen.
  • speaker
    Amen.
  • speaker
    I want to--.
  • speaker
    I want to delve a little on
  • speaker
    your work with the
  • speaker
    World Council of Churches
  • speaker
    as you were
  • speaker
    very extensively, intensely
  • speaker
    involved with the work of the World
  • speaker
    Council. And
  • speaker
    particularly, you had some
  • speaker
    working relationships and
  • speaker
    friendships with the
  • speaker
    two general secretaries during
  • speaker
    your tenure as Stated Clerk: General
  • speaker
    Secretary Konrad Raiser
  • speaker
    and General Secretary Sam Kobia.
  • speaker
    Can you share your thoughts about
  • speaker
    either of those General Secretaries
  • speaker
    and your working relationships with
  • speaker
    them?
  • speaker
    They're wonderful people.
  • speaker
    And the good thing--good
  • speaker
    news is that these are folks
  • speaker
    that are
  • speaker
    accessible to us, and kind of really
  • speaker
    represented the ecumenical movement.
  • speaker
    So we have had a--.
  • speaker
    We've been blessed by having people
  • speaker
    like Sam Kobia
  • speaker
    and Konrad Raiser
  • speaker
    who are two of the leaders in my
  • speaker
    time there. I had the privilege of
  • speaker
    preaching at the installation
  • speaker
    service for--for--.
  • speaker
    Sam.
  • speaker
    Well, for Sam, yes indeed.
  • speaker
    It was for Sam.
  • speaker
    And so any rate
  • speaker
    that--. It's been a rich experience
  • speaker
    with all of those.
  • speaker
    First time I met
  • speaker
    Sam Kobia, we were
  • speaker
    at the General Assembly in 1983 of
  • speaker
    the World Council of Churches.
  • speaker
    And I hardly knew anything about the
  • speaker
    World Council at that point.
  • speaker
    And this African--young
  • speaker
    African youth delegate,
  • speaker
    as I was a youth delegate,
  • speaker
    got [unclear] to us. And Sam
  • speaker
    Kobia challenged me to a tennis
  • speaker
    match at the University
  • speaker
    at--in British Columbia, and
  • speaker
    he beat the tar out of me.
  • speaker
    And it was a--.
  • speaker
    It made me appreciate that he had
  • speaker
    more than just
  • speaker
    rules and procedures.
  • speaker
    That we have--we have
  • speaker
    people that are really human
  • speaker
    and great
  • speaker
    experience in our camp
  • speaker
    as well.
  • speaker
    That's wonderful.
  • speaker
    I should add, by the way, that Sam
  • speaker
    Kobia does send his greetings to
  • speaker
    you. I was with him at the Central
  • speaker
    Committee--WCC Central
  • speaker
    Committee--last June in Geneva.
  • speaker
    So he sends his best to you.
  • speaker
    Well send my greetings back to him.
  • speaker
    I will do that.
  • speaker
    I will do that.
  • speaker
    Cliff, from your--from your
  • speaker
    years at the World Council
  • speaker
    of Churches when you were Stated
  • speaker
    Clerk from 1996
  • speaker
    through 2008, what
  • speaker
    do you remember from your--from your
  • speaker
    work with the WCC during that
  • speaker
    period?
  • speaker
    What stands out to you?
  • speaker
    Well, just to me personally,
  • speaker
    the world of the Orthodox churches
  • speaker
    was really--.
  • speaker
    Growing up as Presbyterian in
  • speaker
    Memphis, Tennessee, you didn't spend
  • speaker
    a whole lot of time hanging out with
  • speaker
    the people from the Orthodox
  • speaker
    tradition, and yet that tradition
  • speaker
    is so rich, so historic,
  • speaker
    and so large. And
  • speaker
    it's really a cause for a
  • speaker
    reassessment
  • speaker
    of the--of the gift that the
  • speaker
    Orthodox Christians bring our way.
  • speaker
    It's sometimes frustrating because
  • speaker
    they are so different in some ways
  • speaker
    than us, but it's also
  • speaker
    a rich source.
  • speaker
    And I think with all of
  • speaker
    the tragedy
  • speaker
    that's going on in the Ukraine
  • speaker
    and the like, you don't see much of
  • speaker
    it in the press.
  • speaker
    But, you know, that's fundamentally
  • speaker
    is also a theological
  • speaker
    argument that's going on there.
  • speaker
    And it's a place,
  • speaker
    I think, that the work of the
  • speaker
    Orthodox community has something to
  • speaker
    offer.
  • speaker
    That's right.
  • speaker
    That's right. Yeah.
  • speaker
    Especially in that--in that
  • speaker
    tragedy that's still ongoing in
  • speaker
    our--in our present time.
  • speaker
    The other--. The other global
  • speaker
    counselor--. The
  • speaker
    other global ecumenical expression
  • speaker
    that you were intensely involved in,
  • speaker
    that you became a leader
  • speaker
    in, was the World Alliance
  • speaker
    of Reformed Churches that
  • speaker
    then became the World Communion of
  • speaker
    Reformed Churches.
  • speaker
    Can you share a little bit about
  • speaker
    that work
  • speaker
    with the World Alliance that then
  • speaker
    became the World Communion and your
  • speaker
    working relationship with, then,
  • speaker
    General Secretary Setri Nyomi?
  • speaker
    Well, if there is one thing I feel
  • speaker
    best about in my ecumenical
  • speaker
    service, it probably is the
  • speaker
    service I've been able to render
  • speaker
    to the World Alliance, World
  • speaker
    Communion of Churches.
  • speaker
    I encountered that new work, first
  • speaker
    of all in 1982.
  • speaker
    I had just been
  • speaker
    elected to, as we said
  • speaker
    in the--earlier about going to play
  • speaker
    tennis with--and the World Council.
  • speaker
    The--.
  • speaker
    Also there was--.
  • speaker
    At that meeting was the meeting
  • speaker
    when the
  • speaker
    whole notion that the--that
  • speaker
    sin is--is
  • speaker
    at the heart of
  • speaker
    the movement of people
  • speaker
    that are--that are
  • speaker
    behind the
  • speaker
    hatred and racism and destruction.
  • speaker
    And the World Alliance in
  • speaker
    those days really gave leadership
  • speaker
    to the world global community
  • speaker
    to work to overcome
  • speaker
    racism, to seek
  • speaker
    not only a proper
  • speaker
    doctrine but to change
  • speaker
    the confessional nature of the
  • speaker
    church. That whole Belhar
  • speaker
    Confession comes out of the
  • speaker
    experience of Christians, largely
  • speaker
    from the Global South.
  • speaker
    And it challenged us all.
  • speaker
    And now, we as a church
  • speaker
    and other churches along with us,
  • speaker
    have added this to our Book of
  • speaker
    Confessions.
  • speaker
    And that has made a real difference
  • speaker
    in--when the questions are being
  • speaker
    raised in our own church about
  • speaker
    how we respond to racism, how we
  • speaker
    make a difference in the world.
  • speaker
    The Gift of the
  • speaker
    Belhar Confession is a great
  • speaker
    resource for doing that.
  • speaker
    And so in so many ways, the
  • speaker
    World Alliance and
  • speaker
    the World Commun[ion] offer that
  • speaker
    prophetic, prophetic
  • speaker
    word, right?
  • speaker
    And the prophetic leadership that
  • speaker
    both the church and the world needs.
  • speaker
    And when
  • speaker
    you and General Secretary Nyomi
  • speaker
    were working for
  • speaker
    the notion of the Alliance becoming
  • speaker
    a communion for the sake of
  • speaker
    justice--I think that was the
  • speaker
    tagline, "Communion for the sake of
  • speaker
    justice." Can you share
  • speaker
    a little bit about that--.
  • speaker
    That change
  • speaker
    of word is not just a change of word
  • speaker
    cosmetically, but there's
  • speaker
    theological substance to that
  • speaker
    from [unclear]--.
  • speaker
    There's deep theology, and
  • speaker
    there was deep debate about it.
  • speaker
    But historically, that has been
  • speaker
    the term that we used for the
  • speaker
    reformed tradition. That's an
  • speaker
    alliance out of a tradition
  • speaker
    that sometime[s] been suspicious
  • speaker
    about the
  • speaker
    rules and procedures and so forth.
  • speaker
    But at any rate, that
  • speaker
    movement stepped aside and all
  • speaker
    of a sudden we were
  • speaker
    in a confessional mood ourselves.
  • speaker
    And that
  • speaker
    was a--.
  • speaker
    At any rate, that was a movement
  • speaker
    that has affected our lives.
  • speaker
    It has certainly affected the
  • speaker
    PC(USA), but it's also
  • speaker
    affected others who
  • speaker
    need a confession that can help
  • speaker
    move along a commitment to justice
  • speaker
    as--not just as a program, but
  • speaker
    as it really the heart of the Gospel
  • speaker
    itself.
  • speaker
    That's right.
  • speaker
    In many ways that builds off of
  • speaker
    other traditions--the Barmen
  • speaker
    Confession being one--that
  • speaker
    has placed us as a reformed
  • speaker
    communion at the heart of
  • speaker
    Christian confessionalism.
  • speaker
    That's not simply dealing with
  • speaker
    rules and procedures, but is
  • speaker
    dealing with the heart and soul,
  • speaker
    love and compassion.
  • speaker
    Amen. That's right.
  • speaker
    That's right.
  • speaker
    In your--. In those years
  • speaker
    leading up to the historic
  • speaker
    uniting General Council in 2010,
  • speaker
    in Grand Rapids, Michigan.
  • speaker
    Can you share a little bit
  • speaker
    what you remember about the--the
  • speaker
    years that you
  • speaker
    and Setri Nyomi were working
  • speaker
    together with your counterparts
  • speaker
    Richard Van Houten and
  • speaker
    Douwe Visser with
  • speaker
    the Reformed Ecumenical Council
  • speaker
    and the merger talks to form the
  • speaker
    World Communion of Reformed
  • speaker
    Churches? What was that like?
  • speaker
    Well, a lot of folks don't think we
  • speaker
    have any business left in the
  • speaker
    confessional theology,
  • speaker
    but it's been interesting to
  • speaker
    discover and work closely with
  • speaker
    another reformed community.
  • speaker
    This one growing out of origins in
  • speaker
    the Netherlands and in South Africa,
  • speaker
    but that, you
  • speaker
    know, that there is a future and a
  • speaker
    present to the
  • speaker
    reformed movement that also
  • speaker
    is confessional.
  • speaker
    Setri Nyomi is one of the most
  • speaker
    inspirational people in my life
  • speaker
    and has had an
  • speaker
    incredible influence on
  • speaker
    the whole reformed Protestant
  • speaker
    movement. He comes out of a
  • speaker
    situation in Ghana that
  • speaker
    needs badly the kind of leadership
  • speaker
    he brings, and he's brought that
  • speaker
    leadership forward to a very
  • speaker
    helpful and creative way.
  • speaker
    Indeed. Indeed.
  • speaker
    Yeah, our--our dear mutual friend.
  • speaker
    He continues to lead there
  • speaker
    the Presbyterian Church in Ghana.
  • speaker
    And, of course, your successor
  • speaker
    as president of the Alliance when it
  • speaker
    then became the World Communion
  • speaker
    is no other than Jerry
  • speaker
    Pillay who's now the general
  • speaker
    secretary of the World Council of
  • speaker
    Churches. And so a lot of--a lot
  • speaker
    of leadership from the reformed
  • speaker
    family to the global ecumenical
  • speaker
    movement.
  • speaker
    Well, and I didn't--. I'm afraid[?] I
  • speaker
    didn't respond to your earlier--your
  • speaker
    earlier comment about the Communion
  • speaker
    moving into being
  • speaker
    an Alliance. And
  • speaker
    replacing--using that concept
  • speaker
    of communion
  • speaker
    is really at the heart of what we're
  • speaker
    about. An alliance is something
  • speaker
    you enter into with people you
  • speaker
    don't fully trust, but you can agree
  • speaker
    on three, four, five factors.
  • speaker
    Communion is something
  • speaker
    that is at the heart of who we are
  • speaker
    and our identity and our being and
  • speaker
    our sense of mission.
  • speaker
    And it was clear in the reformed
  • speaker
    tradition that we had made--moved to
  • speaker
    the point, and we were now ready
  • speaker
    to be a communion and not simply
  • speaker
    an alliance.
  • speaker
    And I think that has really
  • speaker
    influenced our movement.
  • speaker
    It's influenced when we explain
  • speaker
    that. It's influenced our church.
  • speaker
    It's a very
  • speaker
    important development,
  • speaker
    and Setri Nyomi is clearly
  • speaker
    the key to that.
  • speaker
    But also Douwe and
  • speaker
    Richard are people
  • speaker
    that have lived that out and
  • speaker
    represented another
  • speaker
    tradition of the reformed family,
  • speaker
    now one tradition.
  • speaker
    [cell phone ringing]
  • speaker
    Right. Indeed.
  • speaker
    Well, that's--.
  • speaker
    And then the other--the other
  • speaker
    conciliar bodies that you were part
  • speaker
    of as Stated Clerk of the General
  • speaker
    Assembly was the National
  • speaker
    Council of Churches in the USA,
  • speaker
    the Churches Uniting in Christ, and
  • speaker
    Christian Churches Together--three
  • speaker
    national councils.
  • speaker
    What are some of your takeaways from
  • speaker
    those engagements with those
  • speaker
    conciliar bodies in the United
  • speaker
    States?
  • speaker
    Well, I think part of it is that
  • speaker
    we--that it's--it's
  • speaker
    what I said earlier.
  • speaker
    That it's--.
  • speaker
    The movement is not just
  • speaker
    international. It's not just
  • speaker
    the [unclear] on the side of the
  • speaker
    world, but it's
  • speaker
    true to the heart of who we are.
  • speaker
    And that's why it's so important
  • speaker
    we find a way to be engaged as a
  • speaker
    church, because what's
  • speaker
    happening is that, obviously, the
  • speaker
    Christian movement is now primarily
  • speaker
    in the Global South, and we
  • speaker
    need to be connecting all those
  • speaker
    movements in different parts of the
  • speaker
    world that
  • speaker
    can make a difference for Christ.
  • speaker
    Yeah.
  • speaker
    Now of course, when we talk about
  • speaker
    ecumenical and interreligious
  • speaker
    engagement, we have to talk
  • speaker
    about your longtime partner
  • speaker
    in that when you were Stated Clerk: the
  • speaker
    late Reverend Robina Winbush, our
  • speaker
    very dear, beloved friend.
  • speaker
    Heaven's gain, but our loss.
  • speaker
    Can you share a little bit about
  • speaker
    when you called Robina
  • speaker
    to serve as Director of Ecumenical
  • speaker
    [and] Interreligious Relations and
  • speaker
    then your working relationship and
  • speaker
    friendship with Robina?
  • speaker
    Well, I think that maybe the best
  • speaker
    illustration of that is what
  • speaker
    did happen after we offered
  • speaker
    the position of being the ecumenical
  • speaker
    coordinator for the denomination to
  • speaker
    Robina.
  • speaker
    And she said, "Yeah, but I have
  • speaker
    one condition." And I,
  • speaker
    with fear and trembling, walked in
  • speaker
    and said, "Okay, tell me what it
  • speaker
    is." And they said,
  • speaker
    "You have to get my congregation and
  • speaker
    my--and my
  • speaker
    family behind this movement." And
  • speaker
    they have had some hesitation
  • speaker
    over the years.
  • speaker
    But I mean, it was their support
  • speaker
    added to the natural ecumenical
  • speaker
    gifts that Robina brings to
  • speaker
    it. And the
  • speaker
    insightful wisdom that she offered
  • speaker
    made her a powerful dynamo to the
  • speaker
    ecumenical movement.
  • speaker
    That's an excellent descriptor of
  • speaker
    Robina and--a
  • speaker
    dynamo--and that
  • speaker
    heart that she has for justice
  • speaker
    and for the community, for the
  • speaker
    people, and so you
  • speaker
    [are] right on target in that
  • speaker
    descriptor. And we
  • speaker
    miss Robina, and in
  • speaker
    ecumenical spaces, we still
  • speaker
    experience her legacy in so many
  • speaker
    ways.
  • speaker
    Yes we do.
  • speaker
    Cliff, I want to switch gears a
  • speaker
    little bit.
  • speaker
    So still on these years
  • speaker
    as Stated Clerk of the General
  • speaker
    Assembly, once you now go
  • speaker
    to your
  • speaker
    role as one of the agency
  • speaker
    heads.
  • speaker
    And your relationship
  • speaker
    with the various executive
  • speaker
    directors of
  • speaker
    the then General
  • speaker
    Assembly Council or the General
  • speaker
    Assembly Mission Council, the
  • speaker
    Presbyterian Mission Agency.
  • speaker
    Here we're talking about Jim Brown,
  • speaker
    John Dietrich, Linda Valentine.
  • speaker
    Well, those three people and other
  • speaker
    folks like J.
  • speaker
    Herbert Nelson and
  • speaker
    Gradey Parsons and others did--.
  • speaker
    Quickly, just to read those
  • speaker
    names is to celebrate
  • speaker
    that God has given us really
  • speaker
    good people to be in leadership in
  • speaker
    the life of our churches.
  • speaker
    And that is such a blessing that
  • speaker
    you're not spending your energy in
  • speaker
    conflict and
  • speaker
    things like that as a matter of
  • speaker
    daily interest.
  • speaker
    We have lived, I think, in a hard
  • speaker
    place. At reunion back in 1983,
  • speaker
    there was great
  • speaker
    eagerness and
  • speaker
    passion about the [unclear]
  • speaker
    movement, but a kind of--in
  • speaker
    a sense that it's going to really
  • speaker
    move and go places.
  • speaker
    However, nobody quite
  • speaker
    added up all the funds that were
  • speaker
    required to take that over.
  • speaker
    And so we went into a series
  • speaker
    that--. After a[n]
  • speaker
    initial year with the
  • speaker
    three people
  • speaker
    in leadership we've mentioned, and
  • speaker
    others, you know--when the end
  • speaker
    of that first two years period came,
  • speaker
    basically there was only one
  • speaker
    director left, and that was me.
  • speaker
    So I felt kind of lonely at that.
  • speaker
    Because I do think those
  • speaker
    kind of folks--Linda
  • speaker
    and John and
  • speaker
    Jim--they're just
  • speaker
    quality people, and
  • speaker
    they are--they have insights
  • speaker
    and work together.
  • speaker
    And I think in many ways they were
  • speaker
    not given the--as
  • speaker
    great a trust and supporter
  • speaker
    as one would hope.
  • speaker
    [Unclear]
  • speaker
    You had shared in the--in the prior
  • speaker
    conversation that the years
  • speaker
    following reunion,
  • speaker
    and perhaps even
  • speaker
    jutting into the
  • speaker
    late nineties when
  • speaker
    you became Stated Clerk and--that
  • speaker
    the PC(USA) was still trying to
  • speaker
    figure out how to live as a reunited
  • speaker
    church.
  • speaker
    The merger of the mission boards.
  • speaker
    Did you see--. Did you experience a
  • speaker
    little bit of that? Sort of the--the
  • speaker
    vestiges or the residue
  • speaker
    of that from the eighties into the
  • speaker
    late nineties of still trying
  • speaker
    to figure out what it meant
  • speaker
    to be a reunited church?
  • speaker
    Yes.
  • speaker
    Well, it was a--.
  • speaker
    It was a sort of struggle
  • speaker
    about the, you know, what--what's
  • speaker
    critical to being a reunited church
  • speaker
    and not just--. It's about like the
  • speaker
    alliance conversation and communion.
  • speaker
    Internally, we need to apply that
  • speaker
    same notion and really
  • speaker
    make use of a common
  • speaker
    mission commitment. Part of
  • speaker
    what I think is interesting is that
  • speaker
    there have been a lot of changes
  • speaker
    that were coming with reunion,
  • speaker
    and they required
  • speaker
    some changes, give and take.
  • speaker
    But one of the gifts that we were
  • speaker
    inherited from our predecessor is
  • speaker
    that the people working in World
  • speaker
    Mission and Ecumenical Relations
  • speaker
    between the
  • speaker
    PC(USA) and
  • speaker
    other denominations
  • speaker
    really were people that
  • speaker
    pretty much saw the issues in the
  • speaker
    same way. And because we
  • speaker
    had worked in World Mission for
  • speaker
    greater--greater
  • speaker
    common witness and greater strength
  • speaker
    in World Mission, we were
  • speaker
    able to make that transition in a
  • speaker
    way that people in other functions
  • speaker
    of the church's life found it more
  • speaker
    difficult.
  • speaker
    So we didn't have
  • speaker
    quite as much difficulty as moving
  • speaker
    on--moving to the next step
  • speaker
    as some of our
  • speaker
    colleagues did.
  • speaker
    And it--.
  • speaker
    I think it cost us.
  • speaker
    All right.
  • speaker
    Well, in--. During your tenure
  • speaker
    as Stated Clerk and--. I
  • speaker
    recall the first time that you and I
  • speaker
    met back in 1998; that's
  • speaker
    when I started in the General
  • speaker
    Assembly Council.
  • speaker
    You were two years into your term as
  • speaker
    Stated Clerk, but I already got
  • speaker
    a sense of the emphasis that you
  • speaker
    were starting and just really
  • speaker
    carried through
  • speaker
    your subsequent tenure as Stated
  • speaker
    Clerk.
  • speaker
    Your focus on the confessions
  • speaker
    and your focus on--on
  • speaker
    cultivating those relationships with
  • speaker
    our governing bodies, the mid
  • speaker
    councils.
  • speaker
    Can you share with us about your
  • speaker
    commitment to the confessions
  • speaker
    as Stated Clerk and then the--your
  • speaker
    engagement with the mid councils,
  • speaker
    the governing bodies?
  • speaker
    Okay.
  • speaker
    Well, first,
  • speaker
    the confessions.
  • speaker
    I think, I mean, you know, every
  • speaker
    way we expect highly that our--that
  • speaker
    our ministers
  • speaker
    and elders really do
  • speaker
    hold to the essentials of the
  • speaker
    reformed faith.
  • speaker
    We've moved away restrictive
  • speaker
    ideas, which did more to
  • speaker
    a sense of the gift that those
  • speaker
    reformed churches and reformed
  • speaker
    confessions
  • speaker
    can make and do make a
  • speaker
    source of strength for our church.
  • speaker
    What was the other part of that
  • speaker
    question?
  • speaker
    And then the governing bodies
  • speaker
    your engagement with mid councils,
  • speaker
    the presbyteries and synods?
  • speaker
    Well, after reunion, we were
  • speaker
    convinced that it was--we
  • speaker
    must have to develop a new covenant
  • speaker
    with the--with
  • speaker
    congregations and not just have
  • speaker
    the rules and procedures and
  • speaker
    different emphases.
  • speaker
    And so Tom Dietrich
  • speaker
    and I took on the project--I'd
  • speaker
    probably never do again--which--we
  • speaker
    made an invitation to every
  • speaker
    presbytery in the denomination
  • speaker
    for us to come and have a dialog
  • speaker
    together between the Assembly and
  • speaker
    the presbyteries about
  • speaker
    how we might
  • speaker
    use what God is doing in the
  • speaker
    presbyteries as a source of
  • speaker
    real renewal.
  • speaker
    And so that focus on presbyteries
  • speaker
    had an early
  • speaker
    effort. I need to say
  • speaker
    doing those, basically
  • speaker
    about five a week,
  • speaker
    you begin to get a little tired.
  • speaker
    But it's a tiredness that's good,
  • speaker
    and one that helps us
  • speaker
    keep the faith in straight.
  • speaker
    And those were--. Those were so
  • speaker
    helpful and beneficial
  • speaker
    in connecting General Assembly
  • speaker
    with the presbyteries, synods,
  • speaker
    sessions.
  • speaker
    And so thank you for doing that, you
  • speaker
    and John. And
  • speaker
    I recall one--.
  • speaker
    We did a little of that also
  • speaker
    with what we came to
  • speaker
    call affinity groups and
  • speaker
    to try to find a way, which is much
  • speaker
    harder, to get these groups that
  • speaker
    want to stay and want to be part of
  • speaker
    the Presbyterian Church, but have a
  • speaker
    particular angle that they
  • speaker
    care for and want to work on.
  • speaker
    And that continues to be an issue in
  • speaker
    the church, but I think we've made
  • speaker
    some real progress of saying we
  • speaker
    need each other and it's time
  • speaker
    to really focus on
  • speaker
    the things that are common ground
  • speaker
    among us more than
  • speaker
    the things that are different.
  • speaker
    That's right.
  • speaker
    That's right.
  • speaker
    During that period as well.
  • speaker
    I think it was '03 or so--'02,
  • speaker
    '03. There was discussions about
  • speaker
    moving the
  • speaker
    General Assemblies from what was an
  • speaker
    annual gathering, annual
  • speaker
    meeting--the General Assembly--to
  • speaker
    biennial. And
  • speaker
    then beginning in 2004
  • speaker
    and since then, we've moved to
  • speaker
    a biennial, every two year, General
  • speaker
    Assembly.
  • speaker
    What was that like? What was the
  • speaker
    discussions and
  • speaker
    sort of the considerations to
  • speaker
    move from annual General Assemblies
  • speaker
    to biennial General Assemblies?
  • speaker
    Well, in one sense the group I'm
  • speaker
    doing this--this
  • speaker
    audio for is who
  • speaker
    was at the heart of the matter.
  • speaker
    Where particularly, you know,
  • speaker
    there was a sense in which the
  • speaker
    denomination could not continue to
  • speaker
    be a good [unclear] be able
  • speaker
    to afford
  • speaker
    carrying two historical
  • speaker
    foundations. Like
  • speaker
    moving that to one, we save
  • speaker
    a million dollars a year--a year,
  • speaker
    and we do the same thing
  • speaker
    with the--with
  • speaker
    the assembly meetings.
  • speaker
    Those meetings could usually run a
  • speaker
    budget of two, three million
  • speaker
    dollars. If you can get rid of one
  • speaker
    of those in every two to three years
  • speaker
    without sacrificing the--the
  • speaker
    integrity of the--of
  • speaker
    the witness of
  • speaker
    the General Assembly, then you make
  • speaker
    a responsible stewardship of
  • speaker
    that. So those
  • speaker
    were two areas where
  • speaker
    we tried not to be
  • speaker
    moving away from
  • speaker
    things that are really important for
  • speaker
    us. But it didn't seem fully
  • speaker
    that meeting once
  • speaker
    every three year [unclear] meeting
  • speaker
    every two--every two years
  • speaker
    was--was that detrimental.
  • speaker
    And it certainly was helpful to us
  • speaker
    to be able not to--.
  • speaker
    Instead of that, they have basically
  • speaker
    didn't fail
  • speaker
    to continue the work because
  • speaker
    we tried to do it every year.
  • speaker
    Yeah.
  • speaker
    Yeah. And it has worked well.
  • speaker
    It has worked--. It has worked well
  • speaker
    to have it every two years, and
  • speaker
    it allows the--the
  • speaker
    church to, not only breathe,
  • speaker
    but to also
  • speaker
    live into the priorities of a
  • speaker
    prior General Assembly.
  • speaker
    Yeah, we--.
  • speaker
    If you look at the pattern, we've
  • speaker
    basically had our actions
  • speaker
    that we take usually involve two
  • speaker
    years one presbytery takes something
  • speaker
    and it gets to--referred by
  • speaker
    another and you see that
  • speaker
    pattern working in there.
  • speaker
    And biennial assemblies
  • speaker
    feeds right into that.
  • speaker
    Mm-hm. That's right.
  • speaker
    That's right.
  • speaker
    Now,
  • speaker
    when you were starting your tenure
  • speaker
    as--as Stated Clerk
  • speaker
    in '96, did
  • speaker
    you receive any word of advice
  • speaker
    from Jim Andrews, from--from
  • speaker
    Eugene Carson Blake, from
  • speaker
    others as you were taking on
  • speaker
    that--that responsibility?
  • speaker
    Well, Eugene Carson Blake, I regret
  • speaker
    deeply that he and his time
  • speaker
    in the General Assembly had ended
  • speaker
    just before mine began, so we did
  • speaker
    not--. Though I have
  • speaker
    incredible appreciation for him and
  • speaker
    the work to overcome racism
  • speaker
    and the ecumenical leadership and
  • speaker
    the public policy. I mean, he
  • speaker
    is the best of our tradition.
  • speaker
    But I did not
  • speaker
    know him as well.
  • speaker
    The ones I
  • speaker
    knew well were
  • speaker
    the ones we've talked about.
  • speaker
    Who are--. Who are the three we
  • speaker
    mentioned?
  • speaker
    Well, I was asking if, since
  • speaker
    your immediate predecessor was Jim
  • speaker
    Andrews--.
  • speaker
    Yes.
  • speaker
    If there was any word that he
  • speaker
    offered, but then the executive
  • speaker
    directors of the Mission Agency: Jim
  • speaker
    Brown, John Dietrich, Linda
  • speaker
    Valentine.
  • speaker
    Yeah.
  • speaker
    Well, yeah, Jim--.
  • speaker
    Jim Andrews is--when I
  • speaker
    asked him what he thought I should
  • speaker
    do for the next term, and he
  • speaker
    told me to go, basically.
  • speaker
    "You should go graciously out
  • speaker
    and enjoy some of your
  • speaker
    life before you run out." So
  • speaker
    he was--.
  • speaker
    Jim was--. Jim was very supportive.
  • speaker
    Jim was deeply
  • speaker
    committed to justice, to ecumenism,
  • speaker
    and the like.
  • speaker
    But he knew and
  • speaker
    the Assembly, I think, knew that
  • speaker
    it was probably time for a change.
  • speaker
    And I feel that's the
  • speaker
    same situation I'm in now.
  • speaker
    And I think we don't
  • speaker
    want to just have people who are
  • speaker
    very short terms, but we
  • speaker
    want to be a people that can give
  • speaker
    more or less a decade to these
  • speaker
    ministries. And I
  • speaker
    leave, you know, in a sense missing
  • speaker
    it but thinking that this is the
  • speaker
    right thing.
  • speaker
    What were some of the considerations
  • speaker
    or factors that led
  • speaker
    to you deciding in
  • speaker
    '08
  • speaker
    that you would not stand for a
  • speaker
    fourth term?
  • speaker
    Well, I helped write the
  • speaker
    mission design that
  • speaker
    proposed having just that
  • speaker
    kind of recommendation in the--in
  • speaker
    the Standing Rules of the General
  • speaker
    Assembly.
  • speaker
    So, I mean, I was on the line with
  • speaker
    that issue to start with.
  • speaker
    But secondly, I do think the
  • speaker
    church is strengthened
  • speaker
    by diversity.
  • speaker
    And the diversity doesn't have to be
  • speaker
    conflict.
  • speaker
    But if it takes a few years
  • speaker
    to really get in to where
  • speaker
    your system is working with gearing
  • speaker
    with the church's system.
  • speaker
    But my idea [is] if you can't
  • speaker
    make some major contributions
  • speaker
    by the ten, twelve,
  • speaker
    or fifteen years, you
  • speaker
    probably have been there too long.
  • speaker
    So what do you see is as sort of the
  • speaker
    unfinished business?
  • speaker
    So when you finish your
  • speaker
    term in '08, you were made
  • speaker
    the Stated Clerk Emeritus.
  • speaker
    What was, back then, sort of the
  • speaker
    unfinished business if you had--if
  • speaker
    you had continued for a fourth term
  • speaker
    and
  • speaker
    worked for this
  • speaker
    or that?
  • speaker
    What was sort of the unfinished
  • speaker
    business after '08?
  • speaker
    I don't know that I've prioritized
  • speaker
    it--probably hadn't--but the one thing I've been
  • speaker
    think about recently has
  • speaker
    been, you know, we have--we've
  • speaker
    moved--spent energy moving into
  • speaker
    congregational life, into
  • speaker
    presbytery and synod
  • speaker
    development, into ecumenism
  • speaker
    within the Christian commitment and
  • speaker
    what it means--the kind of thing we
  • speaker
    talked about with the Vatican.
  • speaker
    But what we've not done very
  • speaker
    adequately is try to make sense
  • speaker
    out of what all this means in an
  • speaker
    interfaith world and
  • speaker
    in a world that really
  • speaker
    is
  • speaker
    a lot different than we've usually
  • speaker
    done in the ecumenical movement.
  • speaker
    And it's very complicated
  • speaker
    theologically because we don't
  • speaker
    in any sense sacrifice our Christian
  • speaker
    commitment.
  • speaker
    But on the other hand,
  • speaker
    we do realize that this
  • speaker
    is a multi-faith world and that
  • speaker
    God intends there to be love
  • speaker
    and justice between faith
  • speaker
    communities.
  • speaker
    And so I think some real work
  • speaker
    about that--about that would
  • speaker
    probably be very good.
  • speaker
    Yea, indeed. Do you recall of any
  • speaker
    overtures that you made during
  • speaker
    your time as Stated Clerk in
  • speaker
    that respect--interreligious,
  • speaker
    inter-interfaith engagements?
  • speaker
    Is there anything that pops up from
  • speaker
    your memory on that?
  • speaker
    Well, in one sense, the Belhar
  • speaker
    Confession also recognizes
  • speaker
    that.
  • speaker
    The--.I know there [are] constant
  • speaker
    kind of request and demand from
  • speaker
    presbyteries and synods.
  • speaker
    And I think
  • speaker
    we--.
  • speaker
    You know, if you look at
  • speaker
    what--where--what
  • speaker
    we're being requested to do
  • speaker
    is there's a large interest
  • speaker
    out there and that Presbyterians
  • speaker
    are not quite sure how to deal with
  • speaker
    this. And I think it's a--it
  • speaker
    needs to be the focus.
  • speaker
    Mm-hm. Now when--.
  • speaker
    As Stated Clerk, which is
  • speaker
    [a] very outward facing, public
  • speaker
    face of the denomination, you
  • speaker
    were involved very intensively and
  • speaker
    extensively with
  • speaker
    public witness: our
  • speaker
    presence at the--in
  • speaker
    Washington, D.C., at the United
  • speaker
    Nations, working
  • speaker
    with our various offices there.
  • speaker
    Are there any events or
  • speaker
    times that you recall as Stated
  • speaker
    Clerk where you had to perhaps
  • speaker
    go to the White House, to
  • speaker
    Congress, to the steps of the
  • speaker
    Capitol or to the U.N.?
  • speaker
    Is there anything that you recall
  • speaker
    during those years as Stated Clerk?
  • speaker
    Well, I've done both of those
  • speaker
    things. I been to the White House,
  • speaker
    but also been to the--. I
  • speaker
    remember--. It was interesting.
  • speaker
    We--. One of the things that's been
  • speaker
    always--is
  • speaker
    little easy about our
  • speaker
    colleagues is that
  • speaker
    the U.S. government has supported
  • speaker
    and pushed out the school--what do
  • speaker
    you call it?--the
  • speaker
    Latin American school for training
  • speaker
    of war--of people for war.
  • speaker
    And that has continue to be in--in
  • speaker
    support, and
  • speaker
    that's
  • speaker
    a movement that ought to not be
  • speaker
    sanctioned.
  • speaker
    And I remember a day in Washington.
  • speaker
    We were there for the Ecumenical
  • speaker
    Advocacy Days.
  • speaker
    We spent from morning with the
  • speaker
    President
  • speaker
    and other--and other people that are
  • speaker
    in leadership, and then [we] spent
  • speaker
    the afternoon with
  • speaker
    farm workers and
  • speaker
    people that are way away
  • speaker
    from the powerful
  • speaker
    interest worlds.
  • speaker
    And I think that's something that
  • speaker
    can be done, that the church can be
  • speaker
    both an active presence
  • speaker
    in terms of--of programs[?],
  • speaker
    in terms of the poor and
  • speaker
    the outcast and, at the same time,
  • speaker
    can be a voice that
  • speaker
    lift up the call
  • speaker
    to justice at the highest levels.
  • speaker
    That's right.
  • speaker
    That's right.
  • speaker
    I recall that in your
  • speaker
    time as Stated Clerk, you were--you
  • speaker
    were a leader
  • speaker
    in the calling for better
  • speaker
    working conditions and higher wages
  • speaker
    for the Immokalee
  • speaker
    workers who were working--who
  • speaker
    are contracted by Yum!
  • speaker
    Brands.
  • speaker
    Yes.
  • speaker
    Right?
  • speaker
    Yeah. Well, and that was--that was
  • speaker
    an occasion of working with those
  • speaker
    who are, some of them, on the lower
  • speaker
    end of society.
  • speaker
    But I joined the people and said I
  • speaker
    would be glad to be joining in.
  • speaker
    Next thing I knew, they were putting
  • speaker
    a chicken costume on me,
  • speaker
    and I still remember running around
  • speaker
    in the chicken costume and
  • speaker
    after having the [Neal laughs]
  • speaker
    morning with powerful and
  • speaker
    the like. And I got--.
  • speaker
    I got a little flack for that one,
  • speaker
    but people remember that,
  • speaker
    you know, that there was a place for
  • speaker
    the chicken at this--at the table
  • speaker
    too.
  • speaker
    [Laughs] Now you were--. You
  • speaker
    then retired from
  • speaker
    being Stated Clerk--Stated Clerk of
  • speaker
    the General Assembly, and then
  • speaker
    Louisville Presbyterian Theological
  • speaker
    Seminary invited
  • speaker
    you to join their faculty.
  • speaker
    What was that like to move
  • speaker
    from the
  • speaker
    ecclesiastical leadership that,
  • speaker
    you know, that you spent most of
  • speaker
    your professional and adult life in
  • speaker
    and then to move to academia?
  • speaker
    What was that shift like?
  • speaker
    Well, it was better than I thought.
  • speaker
    I--. And I don't mean that--. It was good. That's a
  • speaker
    better way to say it.
  • speaker
    Yeah.
  • speaker
    I mean, I felt like, in some ways, I
  • speaker
    had not kept up my scholarship and
  • speaker
    the things of that sort.
  • speaker
    They're always at the core of what
  • speaker
    we need to be about.
  • speaker
    But I had a group of
  • speaker
    colleagues--some of would have
  • speaker
    different views than mine on
  • speaker
    things--but basically
  • speaker
    a
  • speaker
    group of colleagues came together
  • speaker
    at the seminary to train
  • speaker
    a whole new generation of
  • speaker
    leaders in the church.
  • speaker
    And I'm glad I got that chance.
  • speaker
    I never probably would have been the
  • speaker
    chief academic officer
  • speaker
    for any institution, but I'm glad
  • speaker
    I could make a little bit of a
  • speaker
    contribution to what we call
  • speaker
    practical theology and
  • speaker
    how that's lived out in the
  • speaker
    congregation, the synod, the
  • speaker
    presbytery time in life[?].
  • speaker
    Wonderful.
  • speaker
    Well, maybe in a--in a subsequent
  • speaker
    conversation we'll delve a little
  • speaker
    bit more, in your years--.
  • speaker
    You're probably asking those
  • speaker
    questions too.
  • speaker
    Yeah. No, I'll--.
  • speaker
    Yeah, I will definitely ask you
  • speaker
    in another conversation
  • speaker
    of ours about your--your
  • speaker
    years at Louisville Seminary.
  • speaker
    On our--.
  • speaker
    We have a little less than five
  • speaker
    minutes or so in this--in this
  • speaker
    conversation.
  • speaker
    During your tenure as
  • speaker
    Stated Clerk, those twelve years,
  • speaker
    you served with several
  • speaker
    moderators of the General Assembly,
  • speaker
    some beloved friends,
  • speaker
    and I'm going to name them.
  • speaker
    I'm just going to say a name, say
  • speaker
    the name of one--of the moderators,
  • speaker
    and then just tell me the first
  • speaker
    thing that comes to mind when you
  • speaker
    think about this moderator.
  • speaker
    So 1998,
  • speaker
    when you were elected--or
  • speaker
    1996 that is.
  • speaker
    Sorry. John Buchanan.
  • speaker
    Good friend.
  • speaker
    Okay.
  • speaker
    1997.
  • speaker
    Pat Brown.
  • speaker
    Office next to mine.
  • speaker
    [Laughs] 1998. Doug Oldenburg.
  • speaker
    Wonderful friend.
  • speaker
    1999.
  • speaker
    Freda Gardner.
  • speaker
    Oh, she's a--.
  • speaker
    [I] wish she was elected Stated Clerk,
  • speaker
    I'll give you that.
  • speaker
    At the time, at the Assembly in Fort
  • speaker
    Worth, and I spent my life in Fort Worth. She's
  • speaker
    the best Texan I know.
  • speaker
    [Laughs] 2000. Syngman Rhee.
  • speaker
    That's--.
  • speaker
    He is one of the dear friends in my
  • speaker
    life.
  • speaker
    Yes. 2001.
  • speaker
    Jack Rogers.
  • speaker
    Jack was my portal to the--to
  • speaker
    the polity side of this
  • speaker
    job--to, yeah--to
  • speaker
    both its polity but also its
  • speaker
    confessions. And he really
  • speaker
    introduced and trained me in those.
  • speaker
    2002.
  • speaker
    Fahed Abu-Akel.
  • speaker
    An excellent spokesperson of the
  • speaker
    Palestinian cause.
  • speaker
    2003.
  • speaker
    Susan Andrews.
  • speaker
    Strong, common witness.
  • speaker
    2004--.
  • speaker
    [Unclear]. She was interesting.
  • speaker
    And her congregation was sharing
  • speaker
    with--their building with the Jewish
  • speaker
    community. And I've always thought
  • speaker
    that's interesting.
  • speaker
    That's right. At Bradley Hills in
  • speaker
    Maryland.
  • speaker
    2004.
  • speaker
    Rick Ufford-Chase.
  • speaker
    Oh, he shook up every [laughs] every
  • speaker
    image
  • speaker
    of--of
  • speaker
    how to be a moderator.
  • speaker
    And I remember--.
  • speaker
    I remember trying to get him to a
  • speaker
    dinner with Korean delegates.
  • speaker
    And if--.
  • speaker
    He came down in shorts and a tee
  • speaker
    shirt to this fancy meeting, and
  • speaker
    I said, "We're not going to that."
  • speaker
    He said, "Yes, we are." And
  • speaker
    I said, "Well, I have the key,
  • speaker
    and you don't." So we didn't.
  • speaker
    We
  • speaker
    made that transition, but no
  • speaker
    Rick was--. Rick raised the right
  • speaker
    kind of questions about how
  • speaker
    to really engage in--in
  • speaker
    deeply in cross-cultural change.
  • speaker
    Indeed. 2006.
  • speaker
    Joan Gray.
  • speaker
    Joan is another gifted polity
  • speaker
    expert, and that's
  • speaker
    a good thing that--the number of
  • speaker
    polity people show up in these
  • speaker
    lists.
  • speaker
    Indeed. And then you're--the General
  • speaker
    Assembly that you retired as
  • speaker
    Stated Clerk.
  • speaker
    2008.
  • speaker
    Bruce Reyes-Chow.
  • speaker
    He convinced me that computers
  • speaker
    were here to stay, and that
  • speaker
    I better get with the program
  • speaker
    [laughs].
  • speaker
    [Laughs] Wonderful. And he continues to
  • speaker
    be our social media
  • speaker
    guru and [unclear]
  • speaker
    the digital age.
  • speaker
    Well, Cliff, this--this
  • speaker
    ends this third conversation.
  • speaker
    Thank you so much.
  • speaker
    This is such a fun,
  • speaker
    fun conversation.
  • speaker
    I'm going to end the--end the
  • speaker
    recording at this point.
  • speaker
    Thank you.

Bookmark

BookBags: