Bertram Johnson oral history, 2019.

Primary tabs

Download

  • speaker
    This is Sonia Prescott and
  • speaker
    Elizabeth Wittrig. We
  • speaker
    are interviewing Bertram Johnson
  • speaker
    as part of our oral history project.
  • speaker
    And today is November 12th.
  • speaker
    So our first question. You
  • speaker
    graduated from Princeton Theological
  • speaker
    Seminary in 1996,
  • speaker
    which
  • speaker
    was around the time that Amendment B and Amendment A were first
  • speaker
    introduced at General Assembly.
  • speaker
    Do you remember when you first heard
  • speaker
    about Amendment B?
  • speaker
    I don't remember like the first time
  • speaker
    I heard about it, but I remember the
  • speaker
    conversation about it
  • speaker
    and its impact on seminary
  • speaker
    community and folks moving forward
  • speaker
    with ordination.
  • speaker
    Like you said, I finished seminary
  • speaker
    in 96 and
  • speaker
    was in the ordination process with
  • speaker
    the Presbyterian Church
  • speaker
    and was just in the process of
  • speaker
    coming out.
  • speaker
    And so I
  • speaker
    definitely felt like. Well it felt
  • speaker
    like an impediment. And
  • speaker
    another reason for me to stay
  • speaker
    closeted.
  • speaker
    So I really didn't
  • speaker
    respond to it.
  • speaker
    It was more like an internal, like it
  • speaker
    just added to my discernment process
  • speaker
    on if I should move forward or not.
  • speaker
    And did you decide to move forward?
  • speaker
    So,
  • speaker
    yeah, I stayed in the ordination
  • speaker
    process.
  • speaker
    I was a candidate.
  • speaker
    I grew up in Florida and
  • speaker
    I was working at University
  • speaker
    Presbyterian Church in Seattle at
  • speaker
    the time.
  • speaker
    I had a job there right
  • speaker
    out of seminary.
  • speaker
    So I finished my MDiv in 96
  • speaker
    my MSW in 97, moved
  • speaker
    to Seattle for what was supposed to
  • speaker
    be a year position.
  • speaker
    Moved
  • speaker
    there, met my first boyfriend
  • speaker
    and sort of unexpectedly
  • speaker
    came into that relationship.
  • speaker
    He was a friend.
  • speaker
    He was also involved in ministry.
  • speaker
    We were in a men's bible
  • speaker
    study together, had
  • speaker
    feelings for each other, struggled
  • speaker
    through all of that.
  • speaker
    I mean, this is sort maybe
  • speaker
    way too much more information than
  • speaker
    you want,
  • speaker
    but was starting to come
  • speaker
    out
  • speaker
    and accept myself as a gay man
  • speaker
    at the same time as I was trying to
  • speaker
    move forward in the ordination
  • speaker
    process and had lots
  • speaker
    of questions and doubts about myself
  • speaker
    and how do
  • speaker
    I do this with a sense of integrity?
  • speaker
    There was a position that I was
  • speaker
    offered at, doing campus
  • speaker
    ministry
  • speaker
    in Seattle and I was really excited
  • speaker
    about it, but felt
  • speaker
    that I couldn't pursue it because
  • speaker
    the organization was more
  • speaker
    conservative and they had a
  • speaker
    statement, you know like
  • speaker
    an ethical moral statement that
  • speaker
    you had to agree to this, this and
  • speaker
    this.
  • speaker
    And I just felt like I couldn't do
  • speaker
    it. And so that was one of the
  • speaker
    reasons why I felt like I couldn't
  • speaker
    move forward in ministry at that
  • speaker
    point.
  • speaker
    And then I went to a church where it
  • speaker
    was actually which was
  • speaker
    more accepting.
  • speaker
    And people there knew that I was
  • speaker
    gay.
  • speaker
    But
  • speaker
    still, the broader statement of
  • speaker
    the church is that you have to
  • speaker
    agree to sort
  • speaker
    of this line of reasoning or this
  • speaker
    form of theology.
  • speaker
    And ultimately, it just felt like
  • speaker
    if, if
  • speaker
    the church didn't want me as I was
  • speaker
    fully, then I shouldn't be there.
  • speaker
    And so I gave up sort of
  • speaker
    the idea or the notion of being
  • speaker
    called to ministry
  • speaker
    and just let it sit, because I just
  • speaker
    didn't feel like I could be in the
  • speaker
    church and be out because I had
  • speaker
    really come to grow and accept
  • speaker
    myself as a gay man.
  • speaker
    And then found that the church, well
  • speaker
    knew that the church didn't want me
  • speaker
    and the church had doubled down on
  • speaker
    that.
  • speaker
    At
  • speaker
    that point or further along did you
  • speaker
    ever consider leaving the PC(USA) like leaving the denomination?
  • speaker
    Yes, I did.
  • speaker
    I did.
  • speaker
    There was one point where I'd
  • speaker
    actually been at this church I was at, Mount Baker Park Presbyterian
  • speaker
    Church for like 10 years and, for a variety of reasons had great
  • speaker
    community there. But
  • speaker
    felt like I needed
  • speaker
    to be another place and I thought of
  • speaker
    either there's an AME Church,
  • speaker
    so more predominantly Black,
  • speaker
    historically Black
  • speaker
    congregation that was within
  • speaker
    walking distance of my apartment or
  • speaker
    a Presbyterian church
  • speaker
    Madrona Grace Presbyterian, which
  • speaker
    was like a ten minute drive from my
  • speaker
    place.
  • speaker
    And I went to visit
  • speaker
    Madrona one Sunday and
  • speaker
    I just felt like I have to be here.
  • speaker
    I just knew that its was the place
  • speaker
    for me. Yeah,
  • speaker
    I thought about leaving the
  • speaker
    denomination, but I just didn't feel
  • speaker
    called to it. I felt called into
  • speaker
    the Presbyterian Church.
  • speaker
    I grew up Baptist
  • speaker
    and
  • speaker
    the Presbyterian Church had been the place where
  • speaker
    I got to grow and learn and
  • speaker
    experience life and leadership in
  • speaker
    the church.
  • speaker
    And yeah, I didn't feel released
  • speaker
    from it.
  • speaker
    Can you talk a little bit about the environment of
  • speaker
    Princeton Theological Seminary
  • speaker
    during the mid 90s
  • speaker
    specifically for LGBTQIA+
  • speaker
    folks on campus?
  • speaker
    Well, so I started there in
  • speaker
    fall of 93
  • speaker
    and a Princeton declaration
  • speaker
    came out I think the year before, the spring
  • speaker
    of 93, and
  • speaker
    so that was a group of conservative
  • speaker
    students and faculty
  • speaker
    and I guess staff who signed
  • speaker
    on to this declaration about
  • speaker
    sexuality in the church.
  • speaker
    And it was very divisive and caused
  • speaker
    a big rift in the community at that
  • speaker
    point.
  • speaker
    And so when I started, that was the
  • speaker
    year before I started, so when I
  • speaker
    started that fall, I
  • speaker
    felt like the seminary environment
  • speaker
    was very tender.
  • speaker
    Conversation about sex
  • speaker
    and sexuality and ordination
  • speaker
    had become such a like
  • speaker
    a
  • speaker
    touchstone or
  • speaker
    electric topic on campus
  • speaker
    that many people were not talking
  • speaker
    about it then.
  • speaker
    Because so much damage has been done
  • speaker
    the year before.
  • speaker
    And so for me, it felt like
  • speaker
    conversation had actually been sort
  • speaker
    of suppressed.
  • speaker
    And people, because of the wounds
  • speaker
    that happened just months before,
  • speaker
    people were less willing to engage
  • speaker
    in conversation.
  • speaker
    They happened in small pockets, but
  • speaker
    not as much publicly as they
  • speaker
    had before.
  • speaker
    In terms of your experience with
  • speaker
    different congregations, have you
  • speaker
    always served in welcoming congregations?
  • speaker
    No.
  • speaker
    No, I haven't.
  • speaker
    So
  • speaker
    University Presbyterian in Seattle
  • speaker
    is
  • speaker
    I think it's like four, it was about four
  • speaker
    or five thousand members when I was
  • speaker
    there. The senior minister when I
  • speaker
    was there was a trustee at
  • speaker
    Princeton Seminary.
  • speaker
    And again, this was a time when I
  • speaker
    was not out and embracing
  • speaker
    myself. And so I went
  • speaker
    to the church because I had a great
  • speaker
    opportunity, just going to be for a
  • speaker
    year working in urban ministry
  • speaker
    and putting some of my
  • speaker
    social work skills together and
  • speaker
    helping the church move toward more
  • speaker
    economic and racial justice
  • speaker
    ethic.
  • speaker
    But at the same time, the church on
  • speaker
    the broader level was
  • speaker
    fighting this battle around
  • speaker
    ordination and sex and sexuality.
  • speaker
    So that was the first church that
  • speaker
    I served out of seminary
  • speaker
    and I wasn't ordained.
  • speaker
    But still, there was a lot of
  • speaker
    conflict even in that community
  • speaker
    of a church that size there were
  • speaker
    people there who were more open and
  • speaker
    affirming.
  • speaker
    I don't know of many people who were
  • speaker
    out or really anyone who was
  • speaker
    out there because
  • speaker
    it didn't feel like a safe place
  • speaker
    because the sort of the
  • speaker
    theological battle lines had been
  • speaker
    drawn so clearly.
  • speaker
    And it was obvious where
  • speaker
    the staff and the senior ministers
  • speaker
    stood at that point.
  • speaker
    And so it was not a
  • speaker
    really safe or welcoming place for
  • speaker
    me to be in.
  • speaker
    I was already there as like the one
  • speaker
    African American person on staff
  • speaker
    to be. To come out
  • speaker
    or to express even
  • speaker
    questions about ordination and
  • speaker
    issues of sexuality definitely was
  • speaker
    not a place where I felt free to do
  • speaker
    that.
  • speaker
    So you were
  • speaker
    ordained at Madrona Grace Presbyterian Church. Could
  • speaker
    you describe your ordination
  • speaker
    process?
  • speaker
    Gosh,
  • speaker
    long.
  • speaker
    So, yeah, I finished I'd
  • speaker
    finished seminary in 96.
  • speaker
    I got
  • speaker
    ordained in 2014.
  • speaker
    So I have friends from
  • speaker
    seminary who'd already been
  • speaker
    in their second, third, fourth
  • speaker
    call by that point
  • speaker
    and I don't
  • speaker
    resent
  • speaker
    my process.
  • speaker
    I'm grateful for knowing
  • speaker
    the way that God has walked with me
  • speaker
    through my process.
  • speaker
    But like I said, I grew up Baptist,
  • speaker
    joined the Presbyterian Church in
  • speaker
    college.
  • speaker
    Felt a call to ministry during
  • speaker
    that time. Went
  • speaker
    to Princeton Seminary and started the ordination
  • speaker
    process toward the end of my
  • speaker
    discernment there.
  • speaker
    I wasn't really
  • speaker
    sure if I could be Presbyterian and
  • speaker
    I didn't know any Black
  • speaker
    Presbyterians prior.
  • speaker
    And the
  • speaker
    Presbyterian Church was to me
  • speaker
    largely white.
  • speaker
    I mean, still, this
  • speaker
    is largely white denomination.
  • speaker
    And so there were some
  • speaker
    cultural theological issues that I
  • speaker
    had. Like, do
  • speaker
    I fit in here? Is this a safe place
  • speaker
    for me? And I think also
  • speaker
    lurking in the background was the
  • speaker
    question of sex
  • speaker
    and sexuality and how do I make
  • speaker
    sense of myself at this point.
  • speaker
    So I finished,
  • speaker
    like I said, in 96 and
  • speaker
    I think in 97 or so was approved
  • speaker
    to,
  • speaker
    certified to take a call. But
  • speaker
    again, because of where the church,
  • speaker
    the church was and decisions
  • speaker
    around Amendment A or B, I felt
  • speaker
    like I
  • speaker
    don't think I can do this with a sense
  • speaker
    of integrity.
  • speaker
    And so like I said, I left the
  • speaker
    ordination process.
  • speaker
    I forget what year it
  • speaker
    was. I think I was a candidate for a
  • speaker
    number of years and then just
  • speaker
    decided it doesn't feel like the
  • speaker
    ethos or
  • speaker
    the theology is gonna be more
  • speaker
    welcoming. And so I decided
  • speaker
    I
  • speaker
    told my committee there in Seattle that
  • speaker
    I don't feel a sense of call to
  • speaker
    ministry right now, which is, well I
  • speaker
    don't think it's totally a lie.
  • speaker
    It felt more like this is a way for
  • speaker
    me to preserve my safety in the
  • speaker
    church.
  • speaker
    But I don't feel a
  • speaker
    sense of call to a church that
  • speaker
    doesn't want me and doesn't welcome
  • speaker
    my full gifts.
  • speaker
    And so I left the
  • speaker
    process, I forget what year it was. It was after 2000.
  • speaker
    And then I forget what year
  • speaker
    was it 2012 when the polity changed again?
  • speaker
    2011.
  • speaker
    11, 2011 when the polity
  • speaker
    became more open for
  • speaker
    LGBTQ people.
  • speaker
    And I remember at
  • speaker
    that point, friends who knew me as
  • speaker
    an out man called and said, oh, you
  • speaker
    can be ordained now.
  • speaker
    And I said, well, why would I want
  • speaker
    to do that because I'd left the
  • speaker
    process.
  • speaker
    And again,
  • speaker
    felt that, you know, why should I
  • speaker
    squeeze myself into the confines
  • speaker
    of the church if it really doesn't
  • speaker
    fully embrace me like the polity has
  • speaker
    change. But I didn't know if people's
  • speaker
    hearts had changed.
  • speaker
    And if it was a place where
  • speaker
    I could be myself as an out gay man
  • speaker
    and feel embraced and that my gifts would be honored and free to grow.
  • speaker
    Do you want the full story?
  • speaker
    There's like a whole elaborate
  • speaker
    story of getting suckered back
  • speaker
    into the ordination process.
  • speaker
    Yeah, we want it. If you're willing.
  • speaker
    I was at, so I'd been at Mount Baker for a number of years,
  • speaker
    ten years or so, and then started
  • speaker
    attending Madrona Grace.
  • speaker
    I told myself after 10 years
  • speaker
    at Mount Baker that I wasn't gonna
  • speaker
    do anything at Madrona Grace.
  • speaker
    I'm just going to go.
  • speaker
    I'm just going to worship.
  • speaker
    I'm not going to get involved in
  • speaker
    anything.
  • speaker
    Nothing for at least a year, for
  • speaker
    the first year.
  • speaker
    And the first thing I did
  • speaker
    was sing in the Christmas Eve
  • speaker
    service. And I was working in
  • speaker
    musical theater at that point
  • speaker
    and I sang a solo.
  • speaker
    Oh, holy night.
  • speaker
    And after that, people were like
  • speaker
    you're in the choir.
  • speaker
    It's not like I had an option, just
  • speaker
    like it was like a command.
  • speaker
    And I was like, oh, okay.
  • speaker
    So that was like week 50 into the
  • speaker
    52 weeks I told myself I can't do
  • speaker
    anything at church.
  • speaker
    And so I started singing in
  • speaker
    the choir at the church.
  • speaker
    And within a few months,
  • speaker
    I could see that there was like this
  • speaker
    division between what was happening
  • speaker
    with the music ministry and what was
  • speaker
    happening with the preaching and the
  • speaker
    rest of the liturgy.
  • speaker
    And it didn't feel like things were
  • speaker
    united. And so I
  • speaker
    became sort of this go between
  • speaker
    the pastor and the music director
  • speaker
    who were not I'd say fully on the
  • speaker
    same page at that point.
  • speaker
    And so I could stand in the gap and
  • speaker
    help bridge the two given
  • speaker
    my theological training and my music
  • speaker
    experience.
  • speaker
    And so after doing that for a number
  • speaker
    of months.
  • speaker
    Well, actually, there's there's
  • speaker
    another piece that was.
  • speaker
    One night I was leaving work.
  • speaker
    I was working in HIV prevention,
  • speaker
    research and education
  • speaker
    at Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research
  • speaker
    Center and was leaving
  • speaker
    work one night, walking home and
  • speaker
    getting ready to go to choir
  • speaker
    rehearsal. And sort of had a bad
  • speaker
    attitude about it because
  • speaker
    of some of the frustrations that I
  • speaker
    saw in the music ministry of the
  • speaker
    church, that
  • speaker
    people who loved music and loved to
  • speaker
    sing, but it didn't feel like it was
  • speaker
    necessarily from a place of worship
  • speaker
    and connection to God.
  • speaker
    And I was frustrated in the
  • speaker
    sense of looking forward to going to
  • speaker
    a rehearsal that I was frustrated.
  • speaker
    Like God.
  • speaker
    Like what?
  • speaker
    What do we do to change this?
  • speaker
    How do we make this actually more
  • speaker
    worshipful and vibrant?
  • speaker
    And what I heard God say was like,
  • speaker
    oh, you just need to be their pastor.
  • speaker
    I was like, oh, okay, I get it.
  • speaker
    Like pastor them, support them
  • speaker
    through this experience and help
  • speaker
    them understand how when we come
  • speaker
    to worship and we come to sing
  • speaker
    in church, like we're actually here
  • speaker
    to worship God and we're
  • speaker
    here to use our gifts and our
  • speaker
    experiences as a conduit or
  • speaker
    as a as a bridge that help people
  • speaker
    engage in worship.
  • speaker
    I was like, okay. God, yeah, great.
  • speaker
    I can do that. Yeah, I'll just need
  • speaker
    to pastor them, sort of shepherd
  • speaker
    them through this experience.
  • speaker
    And then
  • speaker
    maybe two months later Mark,
  • speaker
    who was the minister at Madrona Grace at the time, said
  • speaker
    he wanted to talk to me about
  • speaker
    something. And so we had lunch one
  • speaker
    day after church and he
  • speaker
    said, so I want you to think about
  • speaker
    this, but what's
  • speaker
    preventing you from being ordained
  • speaker
    right now?
  • speaker
    And I was like, crap. And
  • speaker
    I knew that there
  • speaker
    was no reason for me not to be
  • speaker
    ordained into this
  • speaker
    role of worship pastor.
  • speaker
    Other than anything that was fear
  • speaker
    related
  • speaker
    and I felt like I could sort of hear
  • speaker
    God's voice laughing at me in the
  • speaker
    background because I'd already said
  • speaker
    yes.
  • speaker
    I said yes to God. Yes.
  • speaker
    I will be their pastor sort of in
  • speaker
    the general sense of I will support
  • speaker
    these people and help them connect
  • speaker
    to their own sense of faith
  • speaker
    in a way that's vibrant and dynamic
  • speaker
    and helps pull people into worship.
  • speaker
    And then when Mark asked me to do
  • speaker
    it, like two months later, I was
  • speaker
    like, I couldn't think of a reason
  • speaker
    or a way to say no that
  • speaker
    felt true to
  • speaker
    what I'd already agreed to to God.
  • speaker
    And really sort of growing
  • speaker
    back into my sense of call and that
  • speaker
    I had questioned to that point if
  • speaker
    a person can lose a sense of call,
  • speaker
    that it may come and go.
  • speaker
    But I think
  • speaker
    I don't think I ever lost it.
  • speaker
    I think there wasn't the place
  • speaker
    for me to to use my gifts in the way
  • speaker
    that felt authentic
  • speaker
    and almost unique to
  • speaker
    who I am.
  • speaker
    So I took a couple of weeks and
  • speaker
    tried to think of reasons that
  • speaker
    weren't fear based
  • speaker
    and weren't just like me trying to
  • speaker
    flee again
  • speaker
    the ordination process.
  • speaker
    And I felt like if I didn't say
  • speaker
    yes this time, it would come back
  • speaker
    to swallow me up
  • speaker
    and I'd be sent to Nineveh,
  • speaker
    somewhere I don't really want to be.
  • speaker
    So I might as well say yes to God
  • speaker
    now and
  • speaker
    accept the call that I had.
  • speaker
    And so I met with Mark two weeks
  • speaker
    later, and it was basically like,
  • speaker
    yes, I agree.
  • speaker
    And then we got
  • speaker
    me back into the ordination process,
  • speaker
    which took about
  • speaker
    I think six
  • speaker
    months I came back as a
  • speaker
    candidate in Seattle Presbyterian
  • speaker
    and then went before Presbytery,
  • speaker
    and even that experience was there
  • speaker
    were some
  • speaker
    challenges around that. The
  • speaker
    night that I was examined on the
  • speaker
    floor of Presbytery, I knew there
  • speaker
    were people who knew that I was out
  • speaker
    and I don't know.
  • speaker
    It was never discussed.
  • speaker
    But I knew that people knew that I
  • speaker
    was out. And
  • speaker
    after I had been examined and
  • speaker
    approved, folks
  • speaker
    from across the Presbytery came and
  • speaker
    gave me hugs and blessings and
  • speaker
    shared much
  • speaker
    gratitude. And people were
  • speaker
    saying thank you for staying in the
  • speaker
    process or coming back to the
  • speaker
    process. And there was
  • speaker
    a guy who was a member on staff at
  • speaker
    another larger church in the area.
  • speaker
    And he
  • speaker
    said, "Hey, we
  • speaker
    love you and we love your church.
  • speaker
    But for the peace, purity and unity
  • speaker
    of the denomination or of the
  • speaker
    Presbytery, let's not make a
  • speaker
    big thing about this." Like
  • speaker
    we're letting you get ordained.
  • speaker
    Basically, like we've
  • speaker
    allowed this, don't
  • speaker
    do anything to upset us now, which
  • speaker
    felt to me like,
  • speaker
    oh, you've been welcomed here,
  • speaker
    but we're gonna put you in your
  • speaker
    place. So don't forget
  • speaker
    that we can sort of make or break
  • speaker
    you. That's what it felt like.
  • speaker
    And so that was, you know,
  • speaker
    within moments of being approved for
  • speaker
    ordination.
  • speaker
    And so it was a sign to me that,
  • speaker
    yes, God has a place
  • speaker
    for me in the church, but it's not
  • speaker
    going to be an easy road still.
  • speaker
    And that even though I'm
  • speaker
    welcomed here
  • speaker
    and there are many people who were
  • speaker
    joyful and supportive,
  • speaker
    that there are still people who
  • speaker
    don't recognize me or see me
  • speaker
    in the church.
  • speaker
    And it felt it feels like
  • speaker
    the way that oppression works in the
  • speaker
    church.
  • speaker
    You know, that women's
  • speaker
    ordination has been approved for,
  • speaker
    you know, over a generation now, but
  • speaker
    still there are churches that don't
  • speaker
    accept women. There are
  • speaker
    churches that are still largely
  • speaker
    white and divided by
  • speaker
    racism and white supremacy.
  • speaker
    They wouldn't name it as such, but yet they would
  • speaker
    never consider
  • speaker
    hiring a pastor who was a person
  • speaker
    of color.
  • speaker
    And in the same way
  • speaker
    for LGBTQIA folks
  • speaker
    that, you know, it's
  • speaker
    a decision that the
  • speaker
    broader denomination has approved,
  • speaker
    but there's still churches
  • speaker
    that would not welcome
  • speaker
    queer identified folks.
  • speaker
    And so,
  • speaker
    again, it felt like this is a moment
  • speaker
    where God's saying, yes,
  • speaker
    I affirm you and approve of who
  • speaker
    you are and what you're called to
  • speaker
    do, but realize that
  • speaker
    you will have challenges.
  • speaker
    And that ultimately,
  • speaker
    I really have to rely on God to get
  • speaker
    me through this experience.
  • speaker
    Could you talk a little bit about
  • speaker
    what the actual service was like,
  • speaker
    the ordination service?
  • speaker
    Some folks had mentioned, you know,
  • speaker
    the extent to which it was very
  • speaker
    personal, very like celebratory moment?
  • speaker
    Yeah, my ordination was awesome.
  • speaker
    I loved it.
  • speaker
    I called it my one man solo
  • speaker
    marriage to God.
  • speaker
    It felt like it did feel like a
  • speaker
    wedding at that point,
  • speaker
    a union.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    it was the longest
  • speaker
    ordination I've been to,
  • speaker
    but I had sort of every
  • speaker
    aspect or the aspects of my
  • speaker
    life that were meaningful.
  • speaker
    I had a Toni Morrison
  • speaker
    reading. I had dance.
  • speaker
    I had Gospel
  • speaker
    music,
  • speaker
    choral music and friends from
  • speaker
    seminary came.
  • speaker
    I'll say that a friend, a dear
  • speaker
    friend from seminary came
  • speaker
    to my ordination in 2014 and I was
  • speaker
    thrilled to be able to take part in
  • speaker
    his ordination service
  • speaker
    just three
  • speaker
    weeks ago.
  • speaker
    Mike Hagman has gone on
  • speaker
    and gotten a PhD
  • speaker
    from Princeton and gone on and taught and done
  • speaker
    an amazing job of
  • speaker
    education in the church,
  • speaker
    but just now he just got ordained.
  • speaker
    And I'm grateful for
  • speaker
    his faithfulness and for his
  • speaker
    dedication to staying in the process
  • speaker
    considering we both finished
  • speaker
    seminary in 96 and so 2019 he's
  • speaker
    getting ordained, got ordained.
  • speaker
    But my ordination service felt
  • speaker
    the feeling was just joy
  • speaker
    and love and affirmation.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    like I lived in Seattle for 19
  • speaker
    years and got ordained I guess in
  • speaker
    the last four or
  • speaker
    the last three years that I was
  • speaker
    there and I'd worked in three
  • speaker
    churches at that point.
  • speaker
    I'd done hospital chaplaincy.
  • speaker
    I'd worked in musical theater for a
  • speaker
    number of years and had
  • speaker
    dance community, had friends from
  • speaker
    all over sort of the spectrum of
  • speaker
    my life who were there and people
  • speaker
    who, you know, church people and
  • speaker
    people with no religious
  • speaker
    faith or no
  • speaker
    formal faith but
  • speaker
    who were all there and it felt like
  • speaker
    my entire community upheld me in
  • speaker
    many ways.
  • speaker
    And realizing that my ministry and
  • speaker
    that I think
  • speaker
    as an out gay man who loves God
  • speaker
    and is committed to the church,
  • speaker
    that just being there, so many
  • speaker
    people who've been wounded by, you
  • speaker
    know this, by the
  • speaker
    experience of organized religion and
  • speaker
    Christianity and the church.
  • speaker
    And to stand in that place
  • speaker
    sort of
  • speaker
    as a bridge between
  • speaker
    sometimes secular and sacred
  • speaker
    lives or, you know,
  • speaker
    people who don't feel welcome in the
  • speaker
    church, but who go
  • speaker
    and to offer them God's
  • speaker
    grace.
  • speaker
    It may not they may never go back
  • speaker
    to a Presbyterian church and they
  • speaker
    may never feel
  • speaker
    like they want to join a church.
  • speaker
    But to believe that God
  • speaker
    loves them,
  • speaker
    whether they're queer atheists or
  • speaker
    whatever, or this notion
  • speaker
    of a God that loves them, felt
  • speaker
    like a really healing opportunity
  • speaker
    for me and for the community.
  • speaker
    And I think that's one of the things
  • speaker
    that was most joyful about my
  • speaker
    ordination for me is that it was
  • speaker
    really a place where all people
  • speaker
    could come and experience, at least
  • speaker
    in that moment, a sense of God's
  • speaker
    grace and justice in the world.
  • speaker
    And some of my best friends who were
  • speaker
    were not religious folks felt like,
  • speaker
    they came and they heard the sermon
  • speaker
    that Michael Livingston,
  • speaker
    who was the chaplain of Princeton at
  • speaker
    that time and has
  • speaker
    been a mentor throughout my life,
  • speaker
    he's now the interim senior
  • speaker
    minister at
  • speaker
    Riverside.
  • speaker
    He preached a great sermon
  • speaker
    that
  • speaker
    that helped everyone to understand
  • speaker
    that they have a role in God's
  • speaker
    justice or justice in the world,
  • speaker
    regardless of if you ascribe
  • speaker
    to a belief in a god or not.
  • speaker
    So it felt
  • speaker
    like what I hoped
  • speaker
    hope for was accomplished in
  • speaker
    creating a place where all people
  • speaker
    could come and feel
  • speaker
    God's love are loved as a whole.
  • speaker
    So the next question I have for you.
  • speaker
    Can you talk a little bit about your
  • speaker
    first full time ordained call at
  • speaker
    Riverside
  • speaker
    Church in 2016?
  • speaker
    Yes. So I started at Riverside in
  • speaker
    February 2016
  • speaker
    and
  • speaker
    my title was Minister of
  • speaker
    Justice, Advocacy and Change.
  • speaker
    And I was on staff there for about
  • speaker
    three and a half years and really
  • speaker
    grateful for that opportunity
  • speaker
    because it did feel like a
  • speaker
    wedding of my passions - my
  • speaker
    experience in working as, well
  • speaker
    in social work. I have a
  • speaker
    Masters in Social Work from Rutgers
  • speaker
    and the engagement
  • speaker
    in the church to move
  • speaker
    in the direction of greater justice
  • speaker
    for all people and the church has
  • speaker
    been an icon
  • speaker
    or sort of a model
  • speaker
    for social justice movements
  • speaker
    in Christian communities for
  • speaker
    decades.
  • speaker
    And it was an honor to be able to
  • speaker
    stand in that on
  • speaker
    that staff. To share in that staff for the three
  • speaker
    and a half years that I did.
  • speaker
    Some of the
  • speaker
    work that we were getting involved
  • speaker
    in with the Poor People's Campaign
  • speaker
    under the direction of Reverend Dr.
  • speaker
    Leslie Harris and
  • speaker
    Dr. William Barber.
  • speaker
    We were involved in immigration
  • speaker
    issues.
  • speaker
    The church has always has
  • speaker
    had a ministry called Maranatha,
  • speaker
    which I think is one of the longest
  • speaker
    running LGBTQ ministries
  • speaker
    in a Christian church or longest
  • speaker
    running. They were established
  • speaker
    in the 70s.
  • speaker
    So I think they just had their
  • speaker
    30th anniversary or 40th
  • speaker
    anniversary. They had an anniversary just recently. And a variety of
  • speaker
    small
  • speaker
    local ministries in ways that were
  • speaker
    modeling and trying to share what
  • speaker
    God is doing in justice ministries.
  • speaker
    So it was great to be there.
  • speaker
    One point that I definitely
  • speaker
    want to talk about was the summer
  • speaker
    retreats for queer pastors, pastors
  • speaker
    that were organized in the early
  • speaker
    2000s. Could you speak
  • speaker
    a little bit about those retreats and what they were like for you?
  • speaker
    So I think I
  • speaker
    got back in the ordination process
  • speaker
    in 2012
  • speaker
    or so.
  • speaker
    And knew of Parity
  • speaker
    or actually what
  • speaker
    was it called then?
  • speaker
    Presbyterian Welcome.
  • speaker
    I knew Presbyterian Welcome through
  • speaker
    Mark, who is the pastor at Turner
  • speaker
    Grace. He
  • speaker
    told me about it. And at that point
  • speaker
    I was somewhat
  • speaker
    reluctant to get involved just because I didn't
  • speaker
    know. Yeah,
  • speaker
    I just hadn't been involved in the
  • speaker
    church on a national level for a
  • speaker
    while and I
  • speaker
    didn't know if this was gonna
  • speaker
    be a community where I felt
  • speaker
    seen and that these were my
  • speaker
    people.
  • speaker
    But I went.
  • speaker
    I was blessed to
  • speaker
    get a scholarship to go and
  • speaker
    immediately felt
  • speaker
    like, oh, these are my people.
  • speaker
    And these are people who some
  • speaker
    of whom had been in the struggle,
  • speaker
    like in the time that I had
  • speaker
    forgone and
  • speaker
    said no to the ordination and
  • speaker
    continuing the ordination
  • speaker
    process, that there were people who were
  • speaker
    fighting and working behind the
  • speaker
    scenes, some folks who were
  • speaker
    getting ordained and they weren't
  • speaker
    out. And then some people who were
  • speaker
    out and really
  • speaker
    pushing their presbyteries to
  • speaker
    embrace the gifts that God has for
  • speaker
    all the people of God.
  • speaker
    And so I was really humbled to
  • speaker
    be a part of that group and met
  • speaker
    some great friends. Friends who are
  • speaker
    now colleagues in ministry here in
  • speaker
    New York Presbytery.
  • speaker
    Reverend Ashley
  • speaker
    DeTar-Birt was small
  • speaker
    group leader then and I met Reverend
  • speaker
    Eric Thomas
  • speaker
    then and also Rev.
  • speaker
    Derrick McQueen.
  • speaker
    And so those were just, and so
  • speaker
    many other people, but those are three
  • speaker
    folks who are here in New York City
  • speaker
    Presbytery who
  • speaker
    are also all African American.
  • speaker
    And it was just
  • speaker
    great to be
  • speaker
    in a queer
  • speaker
    community where I was also
  • speaker
    surrounded by and supported by
  • speaker
    people from the African American
  • speaker
    community, because
  • speaker
    sometimes it feels like you're going
  • speaker
    to have to have one or the other.
  • speaker
    But it was great to be in the place
  • speaker
    where I could be my full self as a
  • speaker
    as a queer Black
  • speaker
    man and and have a sense of
  • speaker
    understanding, because
  • speaker
    just just because we're in a queer
  • speaker
    space doesn't
  • speaker
    mean that it's not absent of
  • speaker
    racial prejudice and sort of
  • speaker
    tokenism that happens in
  • speaker
    the broader church.
  • speaker
    And so I was grateful to find those
  • speaker
    relationships. And now to be in New
  • speaker
    York and to have them as
  • speaker
    friends. Ashley and I just
  • speaker
    co-led a workshop here in
  • speaker
    the presbytery two
  • speaker
    weeks ago or three
  • speaker
    weeks ago on what does it
  • speaker
    mean for your church to be open and
  • speaker
    affirming. So there are church
  • speaker
    congregations that say they are
  • speaker
    welcoming of queer identified
  • speaker
    people, but what does that look
  • speaker
    like? How does your liturgy, how
  • speaker
    does your space show
  • speaker
    that you welcome them? How does the
  • speaker
    signage in your church and the way
  • speaker
    that you talk about God create
  • speaker
    an environment that all people know that they're welcome there.
  • speaker
    So it was great to do that with her.
  • speaker
    Another question that we had.
  • speaker
    Oh and also one other thing. I was just remembering Alex McNeill was
  • speaker
    ordained last month.
  • speaker
    And Alex is one of the first people
  • speaker
    I met that first morning
  • speaker
    there at camp.
  • speaker
    And it's great to
  • speaker
    see his
  • speaker
    faithfulness and tremendous
  • speaker
    leadership skills being recognized
  • speaker
    finally.
  • speaker
    And I wasn't able to attend
  • speaker
    this ordination, but I have
  • speaker
    many friends who were there and just
  • speaker
    so grateful that the church is
  • speaker
    welcoming him in.
  • speaker
    And as the second trans man, trans
  • speaker
    identified
  • speaker
    person to be ordained.
  • speaker
    So, yeah, you mentioned
  • speaker
    that all of you who are at these
  • speaker
    retreats, what were the demographics generally like at these retreats?
  • speaker
    Was there a significant community of color within these retreats?
  • speaker
    Not
  • speaker
    so much a huge
  • speaker
    number of people of color there.
  • speaker
    But I will say to
  • speaker
    the
  • speaker
    benefit and my gratitude
  • speaker
    for the leadership.
  • speaker
    So Reverend Mieke Vandersall, who's also a member of this presbytery, did
  • speaker
    a great job, she
  • speaker
    and John Russell Stanger,
  • speaker
    creating a welcoming environment
  • speaker
    that was really
  • speaker
    use this term in this way, but like
  • speaker
    intersectional in that
  • speaker
    they weren't just dealing with queer
  • speaker
    issues.
  • speaker
    They were pushing the envelope and
  • speaker
    our understanding of what it means
  • speaker
    to be a welcoming place for
  • speaker
    anyone who's been marginalized in
  • speaker
    the church.
  • speaker
    And so, you know, trans,
  • speaker
    Black, white, Latinx,
  • speaker
    whatever.
  • speaker
    That to me, it felt like, oh the
  • speaker
    church is not just
  • speaker
    sort of working from a particular
  • speaker
    box or sort of siloed
  • speaker
    expression of justice.
  • speaker
    It's really this
  • speaker
    group working with Presbyterian
  • speaker
    Welcome really helped me see that
  • speaker
    we're not thinking about God's
  • speaker
    grace in one way, but for the full
  • speaker
    expanse of that and challenging
  • speaker
    ourselves around race and
  • speaker
    class and gender and identity,
  • speaker
    sexual orientation and
  • speaker
    so it's I'm still grateful like
  • speaker
    they're people who are who I met
  • speaker
    that first experience
  • speaker
    in 2013
  • speaker
    that are still part of my life and
  • speaker
    friends now.
  • speaker
    And I feel like we support and
  • speaker
    encourage each other to continue to
  • speaker
    grow because this is
  • speaker
    a lifetime of work.
  • speaker
    It's not just, you know, I'm here,
  • speaker
    I'm ordained. And that's done.
  • speaker
    Exactly.
  • speaker
    Who have been your mentors within
  • speaker
    the church?
  • speaker
    My mentors.
  • speaker
    There are a number of people who
  • speaker
    come to mind.
  • speaker
    I will definitely say Michael
  • speaker
    Livingston, who
  • speaker
    has been a friend and supporter
  • speaker
    since my early days at
  • speaker
    Princeton when he was the chaplain
  • speaker
    there.
  • speaker
    And Dr. Geddes,
  • speaker
    Dr. Geddes and Carrie Hanson.
  • speaker
    He's the first African American
  • speaker
    professor at Princeton Seminary.
  • speaker
    I never actually had him as a
  • speaker
    professor, but
  • speaker
    the senior minister of the church I
  • speaker
    attended in college did
  • speaker
    a DMin under Dr. Hanson's
  • speaker
    leadership and I knew him
  • speaker
    through that relationship.
  • speaker
    And Dr. and
  • speaker
    Mrs. Hanson are
  • speaker
    like my second parents.
  • speaker
    I will see them later on this week.
  • speaker
    And he was just recognized.
  • speaker
    They were just recognized with a
  • speaker
    commission painting
  • speaker
    at Princeton Seminary,
  • speaker
    just I guess last month in October.
  • speaker
    And so
  • speaker
    I think just their care for me
  • speaker
    and they've never pushed
  • speaker
    me to come out.
  • speaker
    They gave me the safe place to do
  • speaker
    it.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    one other person from Princeton
  • speaker
    Seminary again, I didn't have as a
  • speaker
    professor, but Dr. James Kay
  • speaker
    when I was really
  • speaker
    struggling around what was happening
  • speaker
    with our national polity and my role
  • speaker
    in the church, I
  • speaker
    called Dr. Kay
  • speaker
    in his office when I was living in I
  • speaker
    was years out of the seminary and
  • speaker
    I called Dr. Kay
  • speaker
    at Princeton Seminary and said, you
  • speaker
    may not remember me, I'm Bertram
  • speaker
    Johnson and
  • speaker
    I need to talk to someone.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    the thing that Dr. Kay said as I was
  • speaker
    wandering and flailing around
  • speaker
    the conversation was that if
  • speaker
    God didn't
  • speaker
    want gay people in church, God would
  • speaker
    stop calling them to ministry
  • speaker
    or God should stop calling them to
  • speaker
    ministry.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    there was,
  • speaker
    he said this probably over
  • speaker
    20 years
  • speaker
    ago now.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    it just gave me a sense of
  • speaker
    confidence that although the larger
  • speaker
    body of the church may not create a
  • speaker
    place for you, but your
  • speaker
    call, your sense of being
  • speaker
    and identity is really rooted in who
  • speaker
    God is and God's
  • speaker
    selection election for you,
  • speaker
    of you.
  • speaker
    And in
  • speaker
    that, the church and our community
  • speaker
    affirm our call.
  • speaker
    But it first comes from God
  • speaker
    to be God's child and then to be
  • speaker
    gifted and put in ministry in this
  • speaker
    particular way. And so, Dr. Kay's
  • speaker
    been
  • speaker
    someone like I said, it didn't have
  • speaker
    a relationship with, but someone who
  • speaker
    showed up in a particular way in my
  • speaker
    life when I really needed
  • speaker
    some external guidance.
  • speaker
    So those are three, three,
  • speaker
    three people or three or four people
  • speaker
    who've been significant in my life.
  • speaker
    So
  • speaker
    what do you think is next or current
  • speaker
    for the church?
  • speaker
    What challenges do LGBTQIA+ pastors
  • speaker
    still face and what
  • speaker
    do you think still needs to be done
  • speaker
    to create a more inclusive church?
  • speaker
    You know, in the
  • speaker
    in the last few years, as
  • speaker
    folks who were maybe
  • speaker
    more theologically conservative have separated
  • speaker
    and the church has
  • speaker
    sort of reshaped its
  • speaker
    structure it
  • speaker
    feels like there's actually greater
  • speaker
    opportunity for not just
  • speaker
    LGBTQIA folks, but voices
  • speaker
    who've been marginalized
  • speaker
    historically
  • speaker
    in predominantly white institutions actually
  • speaker
    get greater opportunity to to
  • speaker
    be ourselves and to move into
  • speaker
    positions of leadership. So I
  • speaker
    think that's true for women.
  • speaker
    I think that's true for queer
  • speaker
    identified people. I think it's also true for racial and ethnic
  • speaker
    minorities.
  • speaker
    As we lean into and listen
  • speaker
    to the voices of those who've been silenced
  • speaker
    and pushed to the sides and
  • speaker
    create a greater opportunity,
  • speaker
    opportunity
  • speaker
    for them to be at the center and to
  • speaker
    be heard that it
  • speaker
    actually creates this sort of the
  • speaker
    beloved kingdom, this, you know,
  • speaker
    this beloved community that God
  • speaker
    desires for us.
  • speaker
    I think the work
  • speaker
    around economic
  • speaker
    and racial justice are key.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    I know you asked me about queer
  • speaker
    issues, but I don't think we can we
  • speaker
    can't just be a one note people
  • speaker
    that racism
  • speaker
    and
  • speaker
    gender discrimination have always
  • speaker
    been a part of our society,
  • speaker
    and as we make inroads and
  • speaker
    strides there, we also
  • speaker
    do that within queer communities
  • speaker
    too. And so
  • speaker
    I think that probably the biggest
  • speaker
    issue right now would be economic
  • speaker
    and racial diversity.
  • speaker
    Well, racism
  • speaker
    in the way that it's manifested as
  • speaker
    economic discrimination.
  • speaker
    I think that's the broader
  • speaker
    issue that we as a society in the
  • speaker
    U.S. and around the world have to
  • speaker
    deal with. The way that we exploit
  • speaker
    and negate, that
  • speaker
    we delegitimize people
  • speaker
    based on principles
  • speaker
    of white supremacy.
  • speaker
    And as we decolonize our theologies,
  • speaker
    we're actually moving to that place
  • speaker
    where like
  • speaker
    God will create a new earth.
  • speaker
    But we're not there yet.
  • speaker
    We taste it and we see glimpses of
  • speaker
    it. But it's a long road
  • speaker
    and it's a battle that we have to
  • speaker
    maintain.
  • speaker
    Do you have any additional questions?
  • speaker
    I was going to ask
  • speaker
    if you wanted to talk just a little about filming Out of Order which was
  • speaker
    about those summer retreats.
  • speaker
    Yeah. Out of Order. I'm
  • speaker
    glad you brought it up.
  • speaker
    You know, I came
  • speaker
    back into the ordination process
  • speaker
    much later than other people.
  • speaker
    And like Alex's story
  • speaker
    is, I don't know, like 14 years or
  • speaker
    so in the making.
  • speaker
    And I guess mine is about that long
  • speaker
    too, but
  • speaker
    it feels different.
  • speaker
    I'm really honored to have my little
  • speaker
    piece. I mean, I'm the first
  • speaker
    African American to be
  • speaker
    out and ordained in
  • speaker
    the denomination.
  • speaker
    And it feels it's a
  • speaker
    humble.
  • speaker
    I don't know. It feels like an honor
  • speaker
    to be the first and it's just by
  • speaker
    chance because I know there are
  • speaker
    other people who were in the process
  • speaker
    and know Eric and Derrick
  • speaker
    were actively in it before me
  • speaker
    or at the same time.
  • speaker
    Just the timing of it worked out
  • speaker
    that I'm here.
  • speaker
    And so when I
  • speaker
    talk about Out of Order and I know I
  • speaker
    have that designation within the
  • speaker
    film, but I really stand on the
  • speaker
    shoulders of the people who
  • speaker
    are in the process at the same time
  • speaker
    and people who've come before me
  • speaker
    who didn't have the opportunity to
  • speaker
    be out, who didn't get
  • speaker
    the opportunity to share their
  • speaker
    stories or to be fully embraced
  • speaker
    within the denomination.
  • speaker
    And so to be
  • speaker
    recognized
  • speaker
    in Out of Order feels, it's this
  • speaker
    weird gift from God
  • speaker
    in some way.
  • speaker
    But I definitely want to say that I
  • speaker
    am not here by myself and
  • speaker
    it's just by chance that I got to be
  • speaker
    this person in that moment.
  • speaker
    But I celebrate the gifts of my
  • speaker
    siblings, my brothers and sisters
  • speaker
    who
  • speaker
    are still fighting to find
  • speaker
    voice in the church, and I say
  • speaker
    that in the Presbyterian Church and
  • speaker
    churches throughout and
  • speaker
    other denominations too. Out of Order should be
  • speaker
    released for
  • speaker
    public consumption sometime soon.
  • speaker
    There's some emails going around
  • speaker
    around that right now and
  • speaker
    it feels a little dated actually,
  • speaker
    it's sort
  • speaker
    of a historic document now,
  • speaker
    considering how the church has
  • speaker
    shifted in
  • speaker
    the past few years. But I think it's
  • speaker
    good to capture the history of the
  • speaker
    church in our stories of the
  • speaker
    time. And the
  • speaker
    struggle still goes on.
  • speaker
    And there are people who will not be
  • speaker
    approved by their churches or their
  • speaker
    presbyteries for ordination because
  • speaker
    of their identities.
  • speaker
    And I think it's important to have
  • speaker
    Out of Order because
  • speaker
    it does show that there are other
  • speaker
    ways of doing it and that you can,
  • speaker
    if you stay persistent
  • speaker
    in this church, that you
  • speaker
    can find support in there. There's a
  • speaker
    community out there of people who
  • speaker
    know how to love and support you.
  • speaker
    And so I'm
  • speaker
    grateful for Out of Order and all
  • speaker
    the folks who were involved. It
  • speaker
    feels like a small,
  • speaker
    not a clique, but a small subset to
  • speaker
    be captured in history and
  • speaker
    in the
  • speaker
    denomination.
  • speaker
    Well I think that was all that we had.
  • speaker
    Is there anything else you want to add?
  • speaker
    I don't know. Is there anything you feel is missing?
  • speaker
    You know one question I was just
  • speaker
    wondering myself do you find
  • speaker
    yourself in a position where you're
  • speaker
    kind of mentoring the next
  • speaker
    generation?
  • speaker
    I don't. Well
  • speaker
    which next generation. I
  • speaker
    feel that like the experience of
  • speaker
    theological education right
  • speaker
    now is vastly different than what I
  • speaker
    went through. I finished in 96.
  • speaker
    This is 2019 now. The way
  • speaker
    that we talk about
  • speaker
    inclusion and exclusion
  • speaker
    in the structure and theology
  • speaker
    of the church is far more advanced
  • speaker
    than what I got when I was at
  • speaker
    Princeton Seminary.
  • speaker
    And so I feel like there's a
  • speaker
    generation of seminarians
  • speaker
    and people who are feeling called to
  • speaker
    ministry, who are talking about
  • speaker
    the church's history of repression
  • speaker
    in a way that I didn't get
  • speaker
    when I was there. I mean, maybe
  • speaker
    glimpses of it, but now whole scale.
  • speaker
    It feels like we're in a different
  • speaker
    place.
  • speaker
    One experience I did have recently
  • speaker
    talking about the next generation is
  • speaker
    that on National Coming Out Day
  • speaker
    I was invited to be
  • speaker
    on a panel at a public
  • speaker
    school in Brooklyn.
  • speaker
    There were four of us
  • speaker
    and I was the only
  • speaker
    clergy or church identified person
  • speaker
    on the panel.
  • speaker
    And to be able to
  • speaker
    say to these
  • speaker
    middle school and high schoolers
  • speaker
    that I represent a church
  • speaker
    or denomination, but also a God
  • speaker
    who, regardless of what society
  • speaker
    says, loves you, feels like
  • speaker
    that's that's a powerful statement.
  • speaker
    That loves you as
  • speaker
    you are and your uniqueness
  • speaker
    and your uncertainties and doubts
  • speaker
    right now and in the way that you're
  • speaker
    forming yourself that
  • speaker
    God is with you and any religious
  • speaker
    words of hate
  • speaker
    or violence against you
  • speaker
    either your identity or your
  • speaker
    body that is not God's
  • speaker
    grace. That's not how God views
  • speaker
    you.
  • speaker
    And had I been
  • speaker
    13 and heard that
  • speaker
    I think it may have shifted
  • speaker
    my perspective at that point
  • speaker
    of
  • speaker
    those years of self-loathing
  • speaker
    that I sat with
  • speaker
    and those points of self-loathing
  • speaker
    that still come back today.
  • speaker
    It just, you know, those messages of
  • speaker
    not being good enough or
  • speaker
    not feeling safe
  • speaker
    as an as an out man.
  • speaker
    I
  • speaker
    should also talk about my husband.
  • speaker
    I hadn't thought about that.
  • speaker
    So I got married in
  • speaker
    May of this year, May 25th.
  • speaker
    My husband Jason and I got married
  • speaker
    at Riverside.
  • speaker
    We met.
  • speaker
    I moved to New York in
  • speaker
    February of 2016 and he and I met
  • speaker
    in November 2016.
  • speaker
    So we just had the third anniversary
  • speaker
    of our first date.
  • speaker
    Just last week.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    it's great.
  • speaker
    I can.
  • speaker
    I feel so blessed by
  • speaker
    my life.
  • speaker
    It hasn't been necessarily easy, but
  • speaker
    I feel like God has supported me
  • speaker
    through so many
  • speaker
    difficult and hurtful
  • speaker
    experiences
  • speaker
    and the joy
  • speaker
    of having a partner
  • speaker
    who stands with me,
  • speaker
    who affirms me in a ministry, who
  • speaker
    speaks God's grace
  • speaker
    and challenge to me
  • speaker
    sometimes when I don't want to hear
  • speaker
    it.
  • speaker
    Also, I stood for co-moderator
  • speaker
    and Jason was significant in that.
  • speaker
    I
  • speaker
    got a call whenever that was.
  • speaker
    I think that October before
  • speaker
    the last G.A.,
  • speaker
    my friend Eliana Maxim with whom I
  • speaker
    stood, called and said that she'd been
  • speaker
    in this process of
  • speaker
    being approached, being encouraged
  • speaker
    to stand, her
  • speaker
    process of saying, no, I don't want
  • speaker
    to do this.
  • speaker
    But through her own personal
  • speaker
    discernment, felt like she did feel
  • speaker
    called to stand.
  • speaker
    And that
  • speaker
    in her discernment, she felt like I
  • speaker
    was supposed to stand with her.
  • speaker
    And as I remember, it was one
  • speaker
    morning I was on the way to church
  • speaker
    and
  • speaker
    it was very thoughtful.
  • speaker
    And oh, that's really great that you
  • speaker
    thought of me and really humbled.
  • speaker
    And I was like oh I'll pray about this, knowing good and well that I
  • speaker
    really did not mean that.
  • speaker
    I was like, yeah, I'll pray about
  • speaker
    that. Eliana. Yeah, I'm going to.
  • speaker
    Because
  • speaker
    I never saw myself standing
  • speaker
    for co-moderator. I didn't feel like
  • speaker
    I necessarily had the skills to do
  • speaker
    it. I didn't feel like
  • speaker
    it was something that I wanted to
  • speaker
    do.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    yeah, like it just didn't fit in my
  • speaker
    life, period.
  • speaker
    And then I went to a community
  • speaker
    organizing training that was
  • speaker
    sponsored by NEXT Church.
  • speaker
    I'm on the National Strategy Team
  • speaker
    for NEXT Church and
  • speaker
    I was at the community
  • speaker
    organizing training for the next
  • speaker
    week.
  • speaker
    So that Monday, so say I talked to Eliana on Thursday, that
  • speaker
    Monday was training in Baltimore
  • speaker
    and said, I saw the two
  • speaker
    co-moderators so Denise Anderson
  • speaker
    and Jan Edmondson were both
  • speaker
    there. And I ran into Jan
  • speaker
    that morning and she's like, "Hey,
  • speaker
    I'm praying for you." I thought that
  • speaker
    is so awesome. The co-moderators of
  • speaker
    the denomination are praying for me.
  • speaker
    She's like, "Yeah, I talked to
  • speaker
    Eliana." I was like, oh,
  • speaker
    gosh, that thing.
  • speaker
    I wasn't.
  • speaker
    Oh, so other people are praying
  • speaker
    about this? Dang it,
  • speaker
    other people know about this.
  • speaker
    I thought this was just between me
  • speaker
    and Eliana.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    now so she said that she was praying
  • speaker
    about it. And so I was like, oh,
  • speaker
    well, if other people are praying,
  • speaker
    then I actually have to do this
  • speaker
    and went through my own time of
  • speaker
    prayer. And like I said,
  • speaker
    oh, my God, this is great
  • speaker
    opportunity, but I really don't feel
  • speaker
    called to it. I have enough stuff
  • speaker
    going on in my church and life and
  • speaker
    at that point, I don't know if
  • speaker
    we were engaged yet.
  • speaker
    I can't recall where we were.
  • speaker
    Yeah, no, we were engaged
  • speaker
    and
  • speaker
    it just didn't fit in my life.
  • speaker
    And so I was
  • speaker
    I talked at length to Eliana and I
  • speaker
    was like well, no,
  • speaker
    and she's like, you need to pray
  • speaker
    more.
  • speaker
    And then I
  • speaker
    talked I was meeting with a coach
  • speaker
    at that point who's also clergy and
  • speaker
    member in this Presbytery.
  • speaker
    And we were walking just not
  • speaker
    too far away from here in Riverside
  • speaker
    Park. And she said, "So what
  • speaker
    do you hear?"
  • speaker
    I was like, well, I don't want to do
  • speaker
    it. She's like, "What do you hear?"
  • speaker
    I was like I don't wanna do it. She's
  • speaker
    like, "Well that's not are you
  • speaker
    called to it or not?"
  • speaker
    And so I went
  • speaker
    back and I think
  • speaker
    it was that night I went home and
  • speaker
    was talking to Jason
  • speaker
    about it.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    Jason's Quaker and so call
  • speaker
    language isn't something that he
  • speaker
    often uses.
  • speaker
    But I was
  • speaker
    telling him of my struggle and I'm
  • speaker
    not sure about it and he's like,
  • speaker
    "Well, your called to do this."
  • speaker
    And I was like, "You don't know me!"
  • speaker
    And that was. Yeah.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    and I did I felt that like
  • speaker
    how dare you say that, you don't
  • speaker
    use my language against me.
  • speaker
    But there was something about him
  • speaker
    standing with me and
  • speaker
    saying that I will support
  • speaker
    you through this and that God is
  • speaker
    going to support you through this.
  • speaker
    It was
  • speaker
    sort of like the final
  • speaker
    the final sort of
  • speaker
    straw.
  • speaker
    It's like the straw that broke the
  • speaker
    camel's back in the sense that
  • speaker
    this man, who I know loves
  • speaker
    me and I love him, feels that I
  • speaker
    do have the gifts to do it and
  • speaker
    and maybe in there are ways that I
  • speaker
    don't, that I
  • speaker
    have a need,
  • speaker
    but that God would supply that need.
  • speaker
    And so he was he's been a
  • speaker
    great partner in me
  • speaker
    growing and working through my
  • speaker
    insecurities, my doubts and
  • speaker
    ministry.
  • speaker
    And so I'm really grateful for Jason
  • speaker
    McGill, my husband.
  • speaker
    Well, since you did mention it, I
  • speaker
    will bring it up. The NEXT Church
  • speaker
    Leadership Team. Can you talk a little
  • speaker
    bit more about what that is and what
  • speaker
    your role is?
  • speaker
    Yeah. So I've been involved with
  • speaker
    NEXT church for about
  • speaker
    four years now.
  • speaker
    I think I've already completed one
  • speaker
    term on our strategy team and now
  • speaker
    into another.
  • speaker
    And also so it's around this time
  • speaker
    that I was getting more involved
  • speaker
    with the well, getting back involved
  • speaker
    with the denomination, I went
  • speaker
    to a NEXT church gathering
  • speaker
    in Chicago.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    I struggled there.
  • speaker
    I'd been working in public health
  • speaker
    and going to conferences.
  • speaker
    I was doing HIV prevention
  • speaker
    work and education
  • speaker
    in communities most
  • speaker
    disproportionately impacted by the
  • speaker
    virus. So people
  • speaker
    of color, African Americans,
  • speaker
    Latinos, Native American
  • speaker
    communities, transgender
  • speaker
    communities, women and folks
  • speaker
    living in and around poverty.
  • speaker
    So that had been my professional
  • speaker
    life for like four years
  • speaker
    at that point and working
  • speaker
    in HIV as a whole for like almost
  • speaker
    a decade before that.
  • speaker
    And then I went to the national
  • speaker
    gathering for NEXT, and
  • speaker
    it was my first entree back into
  • speaker
    the denomination, the PC(USA)
  • speaker
    at the national level. And
  • speaker
    I think of a conference of five to
  • speaker
    six hundred people that were
  • speaker
    probably three
  • speaker
    or four African American men,
  • speaker
    clergy who were there
  • speaker
    and there were more women, but I
  • speaker
    mean, there were still I'd say less
  • speaker
    than 20 of us total.
  • speaker
    And it was quite
  • speaker
    disappointing that
  • speaker
    it felt like my church
  • speaker
    was less
  • speaker
    invested and interested in issues
  • speaker
    of racial justice than
  • speaker
    my secular job was.
  • speaker
    And I expressed some of my
  • speaker
    challenges around that and
  • speaker
    Reverend Jessica Tate is the
  • speaker
    director for NEXT church and
  • speaker
    I was in D.C.
  • speaker
    at some point and she reached
  • speaker
    out to me and invited me
  • speaker
    to coffee and to talk
  • speaker
    about, you know,
  • speaker
    what was my experience like it at
  • speaker
    the gathering in Chicago and ways
  • speaker
    that I would like to see NEXT church
  • speaker
    change
  • speaker
    as it relates to racial justice
  • speaker
    and I think queer justice and
  • speaker
    economic justice at the same time.
  • speaker
    And yeah,
  • speaker
    she tricked me.
  • speaker
    She got me.
  • speaker
    We had a great conversation and
  • speaker
    I think in some way she agreed with
  • speaker
    my analysis, my evaluation of
  • speaker
    where the church was
  • speaker
    and felt like
  • speaker
    my critique was valid.
  • speaker
    And that because of that,
  • speaker
    there's something that I could offer
  • speaker
    as we were to move forward and grow.
  • speaker
    And so I think I
  • speaker
    came on the strategy team, the
  • speaker
    next gathering, which
  • speaker
    was in Atlanta,
  • speaker
    and I've been involved ever since.
  • speaker
    One of the things I'm most proud of
  • speaker
    was taking part in the Sarasota
  • speaker
    statement, which
  • speaker
    was a confessional statement that
  • speaker
    was written by a group
  • speaker
    of six or eight of us in Sarasota.
  • speaker
    In the
  • speaker
    January of 2017,
  • speaker
    given the events of the
  • speaker
    last national election
  • speaker
    for the presidency, feels like
  • speaker
    the church and the nation have
  • speaker
    become very divided
  • speaker
    where God wouldn't desire it, so the Sarasota
  • speaker
    statement is I mean,
  • speaker
    it's not a perfect statement,
  • speaker
    but it came out of a time where
  • speaker
    those of us who were there were
  • speaker
    striving to add voice
  • speaker
    to some of the pains and the
  • speaker
    struggles that we're experiencing
  • speaker
    around nationalism
  • speaker
    and tribalism.
  • speaker
    And the way that
  • speaker
    the gospel has been used, the gospel
  • speaker
    of Jesus Christ has been used to
  • speaker
    exclude and demonize people
  • speaker
    and to keep people oppressed.
  • speaker
    I mean, like systematically,
  • speaker
    structurally, the way that
  • speaker
    racism was used
  • speaker
    in the church and in society
  • speaker
    as a whole. And to try to put words
  • speaker
    to that so that our denomination
  • speaker
    has
  • speaker
    some talking points and a place to
  • speaker
    struggle to read and study
  • speaker
    and to figure out how do we move
  • speaker
    forward. And so that's one of the
  • speaker
    things that I'm really proud to
  • speaker
    have been able to take part in through NEXT.
  • speaker
    And we are
  • speaker
    we're still struggling to do
  • speaker
    the work of justice and to really
  • speaker
    change our institutional structure
  • speaker
    around oppression as a whole.
  • speaker
    It's a lot of work.
  • speaker
    And we
  • speaker
    have hard times on a regular basis.
  • speaker
    But I'm grateful for
  • speaker
    my colleagues in ministry who are
  • speaker
    willing to to listen
  • speaker
    and the people who are willing to
  • speaker
    speak their voices
  • speaker
    and to struggle and to sit with
  • speaker
    difficulty, because it does feel
  • speaker
    like in this place we are
  • speaker
    birthing a new experience of
  • speaker
    the church.
  • speaker
    The next experience of the church.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    I do like I appreciate the
  • speaker
    name NEXT church because
  • speaker
    we never fully get there.
  • speaker
    It's not NOW church, it's the
  • speaker
    church we're growing into
  • speaker
    and we're still being shaped by
  • speaker
    God and the teachings of Jesus
  • speaker
    every day.
  • speaker
    So as I talk about not necessarily
  • speaker
    like a mentor, but a person who's
  • speaker
    been a dear friend to me since
  • speaker
    I moved to New York and significant
  • speaker
    in my life is Fred Davie,
  • speaker
    who is an out
  • speaker
    gay Presbyterian man,
  • speaker
    African American Presbyterian
  • speaker
    pastor, and he's
  • speaker
    the reason I'm married
  • speaker
    in large part.
  • speaker
    Jason, my fiancee
  • speaker
    or at that point was not.
  • speaker
    Jason,
  • speaker
    my husband, I'd written
  • speaker
    him on OkCupid. This is really way too, we'll figure out if you need this
  • speaker
    or not.
  • speaker
    So Jason, I'd written
  • speaker
    him on OkCupid
  • speaker
    and he wrote me back, but I hadn't
  • speaker
    gone for a couple of weeks.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    during that time he stalked me
  • speaker
    because he had my name that I'd
  • speaker
    worked in HIV.
  • speaker
    And, yeah I don't know. This is not even useful.
  • speaker
    Yeah it is, keep going.
  • speaker
    Is it, really?
  • speaker
    We'll listen to you, yeah.
  • speaker
    So he had my name that I worked in
  • speaker
    HIV and had lived in
  • speaker
    Seattle.
  • speaker
    And he put those three pieces
  • speaker
    together
  • speaker
    in the Google machine.
  • speaker
    And my bio at
  • speaker
    Riverside Church came up at that
  • speaker
    point.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    he's like, that's not that guy.
  • speaker
    But it was me.
  • speaker
    And through those three
  • speaker
    pieces was able to figure out, well,
  • speaker
    he's friends with Fred Davie.
  • speaker
    Fred was or is
  • speaker
    the vice president at Union
  • speaker
    Theological Seminary.
  • speaker
    Out gay Presbyterian pastor,
  • speaker
    African American.
  • speaker
    And so Jason called
  • speaker
    Fred and said, well, they've got to
  • speaker
    know each other.
  • speaker
    And Fred and I had just had lunch.
  • speaker
    He'd been a friend to
  • speaker
    me since I arrived in New York.
  • speaker
    And
  • speaker
    Jason called him, talked to him.
  • speaker
    And Fred
  • speaker
    gave me a call and said, hey,
  • speaker
    there's this guy who
  • speaker
    wants to talk to you.
  • speaker
    And I was like no, that's
  • speaker
    unappealing. Why would I do that?
  • speaker
    Someone's stalking me.
  • speaker
    No.
  • speaker
    He was like, well, you wrote him.
  • speaker
    And I was like I didn't write
  • speaker
    anybody.
  • speaker
    And he was like OkCupid?
  • speaker
    And I was like, yeah,
  • speaker
    there's this guy.
  • speaker
    And so he's like, he's
  • speaker
    a good guy. You should talk to him.
  • speaker
    And I was like, well, because you
  • speaker
    say so, Fred, I will
  • speaker
    give him a call, but I will not be
  • speaker
    nice to him. No, I didn't say that.
  • speaker
    But then Jason and
  • speaker
    I talked the next night and
  • speaker
    then we had our first date the
  • speaker
    following Sunday.
  • speaker
    And yeah, we've been together ever
  • speaker
    since. But Fred Davie has been
  • speaker
    a significant part of my life.
  • speaker
    And he performed our wedding
  • speaker
    ceremony, he and Michael Livingston.
  • speaker
    And so it was great to be able to
  • speaker
    recognize him. And that I mean
  • speaker
    Fred is doing tremendous work
  • speaker
    at Union and sort of a
  • speaker
    broader political system here in New
  • speaker
    York, overseeing
  • speaker
    the citizens review board with the
  • speaker
    police department and
  • speaker
    I'm grateful for him in the way
  • speaker
    that his ministry
  • speaker
    is not just in the congregational
  • speaker
    context, but
  • speaker
    he's just like another example of
  • speaker
    the way queer people are serving the
  • speaker
    church and maybe not always in in
  • speaker
    the confines of a church,
  • speaker
    but leading us for justice, too.
  • speaker
    And so I'm grateful for Fred Davie.

Bookmark

BookBags: